Meeting 2021 01 22
Friday 22 January 2021 12h UTC
MS Teams
- Tom Kralidis (lead TT-WISMD, chair ET-Metadata)
- Guillaume Aubert (EUMETSAT)
- Ján Osuský (HMEI)
- Julia Sieland (Germany)
- Marta Gutierrez (ECMWF)
- Xinqiang Han (CMA)
- Anna Milan (WMO)
- Xiaoxia Chen (WMO)
- Previous meeting minutes and actions (5 minutes)
- KPI checklist review https://github.com/wmo-im/wcmp/issues/68 (remainder)
- Scoring rubric
The teams firstly review the actions of the previous meeting (https://github.com/wmo-im/tt-wismd/wiki/Meeting-2021-01-08) and then discuss the remaining KPI checklist.
- KPI C Good quality abstract
- Action: TK to approve and to merge the branch (DONE)
- KPI E temporal information
- Action: GA to add an example in codelistValue=ongoing, and in maintenanceFrequencyCode then open up a pull request
- KPI K Data policy
- Decision: approved (DONE)
- KPI L Distribution Info
- Decision: To change from "1 for each transfer option" to "1 for at least one transfer option"
- Action: TK to update and reword "Format is identified" (DONE)
- Action: TK to reword "Distributor contact organization is identified" (DONE)
- Action: AM to open an issue for authoritative URL links to reference for WMO data specifications
- Action: MG to check all the versions and URLs and links we are referring to
- KPI M Codelists validation
- Note, the 2012 URL for WMO codelists is more authoritative than 2013 version
- Action: ALL per #69 Check all the issues for reference consistency (part of final step)
- Action: TK to open an issue to discuss the reference updates in another meeting
- Action: MG to review Part 2 on validating codelists
- Action: TK to double-check the values and attributes of the codelist
- Decision: remove test for 'presence of authoritative codelist URLs', don't test for use of anchors (accept anchors or characterStrings)
- KPI D Valid station identifier
- not discussed/deferred to next meeting (out of time)
- The team will check the description of each rule for a score in each KPI. (KPI L)
- KPI L: Get 1 point for at least one transfer option
- KPI L: Double-check the MD format before removing "Format is identified" (DONE)
- GA: open an issue to determine how to validate codelist URLs
- AM: open an issue for authoritative URL links
- TK: check the MD format, codelist values and attributes (DONE)
- MG: review Part 2 codelist validation
