Agenda for Jul 20, 2023

[nairnandu]

Here is the proposed agenda for the July 20th meeting:

• Interop 2024 brainstorming #331
• Test change proposals
  • Add rgb() parsing tests that include non-finite inputs #369
  • Remove WebCodecs tests with PRECONDITION_FAILED #375

[nairnandu]

Attendees: @boazsender, @nairnandu, @dandclark, @jgraham, @gsnedders, @bkardell

• jgraham: consider moving this meeting to a weekly cadence as we get closer to the timeline for proposal selection
• Interop 2024 brainstorming #331
  • nairnandu: based on our last discussion, are there data points that we can move upstream as optional fields in the proposal template?
  • jgraham: moving some of the data requirements into the proposal template would make sense.
  • boazsender: aside from the proposal template, I think we should still discuss what data is reasonable to collect. We can do that next time when we have the full group
  • jgraham: makes sense to have a shared location for the data associated with a proposal.
  • AI: Add to the agenda for next meeting since there is a small group in attendance today
• Test change proposals
  • Add rgb() parsing tests that include non-finite inputs #369
    • gsnedders: agree to exclude since there is an ongoing discussion
    • jgraham: another option would be to split the test file and mark it .tentative
  • Remove WebCodecs tests for AV1 codec #375
    • Discussion happening in Treat 'PRECONDITION_FAILED' as 'PASS' for interop scoring purposes results-analysis#178
    • jgraham: changing the test-set to include only the ones that test interoperability seems to be a reasonable thing to do
    • gsnedders: for BSF we do pass tests where pre-condition fails
    • jgraham: one of the problems with BSF is that the tests are not sufficiently curated. The easy way would be to remove tests for codecs that are not supported on all 3 engines