diff --git a/weave-js/src/components/PagePanelComponents/Home/Browse3/pages/CompareEvaluationsPage/sections/SummaryPlotsSection/SummaryPlotsSection.tsx b/weave-js/src/components/PagePanelComponents/Home/Browse3/pages/CompareEvaluationsPage/sections/SummaryPlotsSection/SummaryPlotsSection.tsx
index c23ffcce04d..a66fe24f57f 100644
--- a/weave-js/src/components/PagePanelComponents/Home/Browse3/pages/CompareEvaluationsPage/sections/SummaryPlotsSection/SummaryPlotsSection.tsx
+++ b/weave-js/src/components/PagePanelComponents/Home/Browse3/pages/CompareEvaluationsPage/sections/SummaryPlotsSection/SummaryPlotsSection.tsx
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ export const SummaryPlots: React.FC<{
   state: EvaluationComparisonState;
   setSelectedMetrics: (newModel: Record<string, boolean>) => void;
 }> = ({state, setSelectedMetrics}) => {
-  const {radarData, allMetricNames} = useNormalizedPlotDataFromMetrics(state);
+  const {radarData, allMetricNames} = usePlotDataFromMetrics(state);
   const {selectedMetrics} = state;
 
   // Initialize selectedMetrics if null
@@ -237,11 +237,10 @@ const useFilteredData = (
     return data;
   }, [radarData, selectedMetrics]);
 
-function getMetricValuesFromRadarData(radarData: RadarPlotData): {
+function getMetricValuesMap(radarData: RadarPlotData): {
   [metric: string]: number[];
 } {
   const metricValues: {[metric: string]: number[]} = {};
-  // Gather all values for each metric
   Object.values(radarData).forEach(callData => {
     Object.entries(callData.metrics).forEach(([metric, value]) => {
       if (!metricValues[metric]) {
@@ -253,37 +252,54 @@ function getMetricValuesFromRadarData(radarData: RadarPlotData): {
   return metricValues;
 }
 
-function getMetricMinsFromRadarData(radarData: RadarPlotData): {
-  [metric: string]: number;
+function normalizeMetricValues(values: number[]): {
+  normalizedValues: number[];
+  normalizer: number;
 } {
-  const metricValues = getMetricValuesFromRadarData(radarData);
-  const metricMins: {[metric: string]: number} = {};
-  Object.entries(metricValues).forEach(([metric, values]) => {
-    metricMins[metric] = Math.min(...values);
-  });
-  return metricMins;
+  const min = Math.min(...values);
+  const max = Math.max(...values);
+
+  if (min === max) {
+    return {
+      normalizedValues: values.map(() => 0.5),
+      normalizer: 1,
+    };
+  }
+
+  // Handle negative values by shifting
+  const shiftedValues = min < 0 ? values.map(v => v - min) : values;
+  const maxValue = min < 0 ? max - min : max;
+
+  const maxPower = Math.ceil(Math.log2(maxValue));
+  const normalizer = Math.pow(2, maxPower);
+
+  return {
+    normalizedValues: shiftedValues.map(v => v / normalizer),
+    normalizer,
+  };
 }
 
-function normalizeDataForRadarPlot(radarData: RadarPlotData): RadarPlotData {
-  const metricMins = getMetricMinsFromRadarData(radarData);
+function normalizeDataForRadarPlot(
+  radarDataOriginal: RadarPlotData
+): RadarPlotData {
+  const radarData = Object.fromEntries(
+    Object.entries(radarDataOriginal).map(([callId, callData]) => [
+      callId,
+      {...callData, metrics: {...callData.metrics}},
+    ])
+  );
 
-  const normalizedData: RadarPlotData = {};
-  Object.entries(radarData).forEach(([callId, callData]) => {
-    normalizedData[callId] = {
-      name: callData.name,
-      color: callData.color,
-      metrics: {},
-    };
+  const metricValues = getMetricValuesMap(radarData);
 
-    Object.entries(callData.metrics).forEach(([metric, value]) => {
-      const min = metricMins[metric];
-      // Only shift values if there are negative values
-      const normalizedValue = min < 0 ? value - min : value;
-      normalizedData[callId].metrics[metric] = normalizedValue;
+  // Normalize each metric independently
+  Object.entries(metricValues).forEach(([metric, values]) => {
+    const {normalizedValues} = normalizeMetricValues(values);
+    Object.values(radarData).forEach((callData, index) => {
+      callData.metrics[metric] = normalizedValues[index];
     });
   });
 
-  return normalizedData;
+  return radarData;
 }
 
 const useBarPlotData = (filteredData: RadarPlotData) =>
@@ -408,16 +424,7 @@ const usePaginatedPlots = (
   return {plotsToShow, totalPlots, startIndex, endIndex, totalPages};
 };
 
-function normalizeValues(values: Array<number | undefined>): number[] {
-  // find the max value
-  // find the power of 2 that is greater than the max value
-  // divide all values by that power of 2
-  const maxVal = Math.max(...(values.filter(v => v !== undefined) as number[]));
-  const maxPower = Math.ceil(Math.log2(maxVal));
-  return values.map(val => (val ? val / 2 ** maxPower : 0));
-}
-
-const useNormalizedPlotDataFromMetrics = (
+const usePlotDataFromMetrics = (
   state: EvaluationComparisonState
 ): {radarData: RadarPlotData; allMetricNames: Set<string>} => {
   const compositeMetrics = useMemo(() => {
@@ -428,7 +435,7 @@ const useNormalizedPlotDataFromMetrics = (
   }, [state]);
 
   return useMemo(() => {
-    const normalizedMetrics = Object.values(compositeMetrics)
+    const metrics = Object.values(compositeMetrics)
       .map(scoreGroup => Object.values(scoreGroup.metrics))
       .flat()
       .map(metric => {
@@ -449,11 +456,8 @@ const useNormalizedPlotDataFromMetrics = (
             return val;
           }
         });
-        const normalizedValues = normalizeValues(values);
         const evalScores: {[evalCallId: string]: number | undefined} =
-          Object.fromEntries(
-            callIds.map((key, i) => [key, normalizedValues[i]])
-          );
+          Object.fromEntries(callIds.map((key, i) => [key, values[i]]));
 
         const metricLabel = flattenedDimensionPath(
           Object.values(metric.scorerRefs)[0].metric
@@ -472,7 +476,7 @@ const useNormalizedPlotDataFromMetrics = (
             name: evalCall.name,
             color: evalCall.color,
             metrics: Object.fromEntries(
-              normalizedMetrics.map(metric => {
+              metrics.map(metric => {
                 return [
                   metric.metricLabel,
                   metric.evalScores[evalCall.callId] ?? 0,
@@ -483,7 +487,7 @@ const useNormalizedPlotDataFromMetrics = (
         ];
       })
     );
-    const allMetricNames = new Set(normalizedMetrics.map(m => m.metricLabel));
+    const allMetricNames = new Set(metrics.map(m => m.metricLabel));
     return {radarData, allMetricNames};
   }, [callIds, compositeMetrics, state.data.evaluationCalls]);
 };