Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

macOS 14.x Compatibility #127

Open
WadeWu55 opened this issue Jan 27, 2024 · 22 comments
Open

macOS 14.x Compatibility #127

WadeWu55 opened this issue Jan 27, 2024 · 22 comments
Labels
question Further information is requested

Comments

@WadeWu55
Copy link

Hi,

I just updated my m2 MacBook Air to Mac OS version 14.3, then I find this app does not work with this version at all. My previous system language is Chinese and the app work well with Mac OS version 14.2. I already change my system language to English and restart Mac plus Apple Music several times, unfortunately it still does not work. could you please help me with this?

@TomHyp3
Copy link

TomHyp3 commented Feb 8, 2024

Same Problem here. Doesn‘t work under Sonoma 14.3 on a Mac Mini M2.

@TomHyp3
Copy link

TomHyp3 commented Feb 8, 2024

After a few restarts and a new installation, it strangely runs again. My systemlanguage is in german btw.

@WadeWu55
Copy link
Author

After a few restarts and a new installation, it strangely runs again. My systemlanguage is in german btw.

That is great. I have reinstalled my system to 13.6.4, it works well again!

@vyconm
Copy link

vyconm commented Mar 1, 2024

hm, I am also running 14.3 and do not have any issues running the latest beta. Logs would be helpful

@vincentneo
Copy link
Owner

I did a quick test with macOS 14.4 and LosslessSwitcher 1.1, seems to work fine.

@vincentneo vincentneo changed the title The app can not work under Mac OS version 14.3 macOS 14.x Compatibility Mar 10, 2024
@vincentneo vincentneo added the question Further information is requested label Mar 10, 2024
@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 13, 2024

Version 1.1 - Build 18.
14.4.1 (23E224) + Apple M2 + Apple Music.
Works unstable. Mostly only when downgrades.

@vyconm
Copy link

vyconm commented Apr 14, 2024

If you have issues, please try to be more specific, like:

  • What kind of issues?
  • When are you experiencing issues?
  • What are the Specs of your Mac?
  • What Audio Interface are you using?
  • What Ausio Player / Service are you using?

Due to the nature of this app, there are a lot of variables and issue points that do not come from the software itself, but things like Audio Interfaces, User Settings etc., and they need to be isolated to really help development.

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 14, 2024

Version 1.1 - Build 18.
14.4.1 (23E224) + Apple M2 + Apple Music.
Player Swinsian
Output Mac book speaker.
24-bit / 192 kHz FLAC sample.

3

@vincentneo
Copy link
Owner

@vyconm thanks for this comment!

It’s always important to know more specific info about what’s going to fully understand the issue!

@vincentneo
Copy link
Owner

Player Swinsian
192kHz FLAC

@Ikimura Are you using Swinsian for playback of a FLAC file? LosslessSwitcher is only designed and intended for use with the official Apple Music app, when streaming Lossless content.

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 14, 2024

Player Swinsian
192kHz FLAC

@Ikimura Are you using Swinsian for playback of a FLAC file? LosslessSwitcher is only designed and intended for use with the official Apple Music app, when streaming Lossless content.

The same for Apple Music & Lossless content but LosslessSwitcher shows 44.1kHz.
4
5

@MasterRahool
Copy link
Contributor

Player Swinsian
192kHz FLAC

@Ikimura Are you using Swinsian for playback of a FLAC file? LosslessSwitcher is only designed and intended for use with the official Apple Music app, when streaming Lossless content.

The same for Apple Music & Lossless content but LosslessSwitcher shows 44.1kHz. 4 5

Are you saying you're playing a 44.1k track on Apple Music but Lossless Switcher is showing 48k?

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 14, 2024

Player Swinsian
192kHz FLAC

@Ikimura Are you using Swinsian for playback of a FLAC file? LosslessSwitcher is only designed and intended for use with the official Apple Music app, when streaming Lossless content.

The same for Apple Music & Lossless content but LosslessSwitcher shows 44.1kHz. 4 5

Are you saying you're playing a 44.1k track on Apple Music but Lossless Switcher is showing 48k?

No, I was assuming that Apple Music uses highest option from settings i.e.24-bit/192kHz for the content but looks like 90% of content is 48 at best or Switcher doesn't work for me.

@MasterRahool
Copy link
Contributor

No, I was assuming that Apple Music uses highest option from settings i.e.24-bit/192kHz for the content but looks like 90% of content is 48 at best or Switcher doesn't work for me.

ah yeah most music is CD Quality with some more 48k albums in the mix, higher options should have the "Hi-Res Lossless" logo on the album page

@vincentneo
Copy link
Owner

vincentneo commented Apr 14, 2024

No, I was assuming that Apple Music uses highest option from settings i.e.24-bit/192kHz for the content but looks like 90% of content is 48 at best or Switcher doesn't work for me.

@Ikimura you should be able to tell the exact sample rate of the currently playing album by clicking on the lossless icon (in Apple Music app)

example: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/252844950?answerId=255356260022&sortBy=best#255356260022

In Apple context:
Lossless can refer to non lossy compressed, 44.1 or 48kHz audio.
Hi Res Lossless refers to non lossy compressed, 96 or 192kHz audio. (Theoretically, 88.2 and 176.4 as well, though I don’t think I’ve seen it before)

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 14, 2024

Still found few cases of mismatch.
6
7

@MasterRahool
Copy link
Contributor

Are they mismatched when playing the full album or are they in a playlist and LSS is doing the error where it pulls the following track's info?

(I have a handful of 88k albums saved, only 176k I know of is Abraxas by Santana)

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 15, 2024

Are they mismatched when playing the full album or are they in a playlist and LSS is doing the error where it pulls the following track's info?

In both cases.
Even your example shows different data.
9

@vincentneo
Copy link
Owner

@Ikimura Can I check with you on whether if bit depth switching makes a difference in your case (and whether if it is on/off in your case?) thanks

Screenshot

@MasterRahool
Copy link
Contributor

MasterRahool commented Apr 15, 2024

hmmm....so playing 176k songs switches to 96, and other tracks switch to 48 max?

is the DAC (via USB?) manually selected?

In a previous screenshot it showed macbook air being the device, Mac speakers support 44, 48, 88, and 96k which would explain a 96 ceiling on a 176k track (but not a 48k ceiling previously mentioned)

@vincentneo
Copy link
Owner

Mac speakers support 44, 48, 88, and 96k which would explain a 96 ceiling on a 176k track (but not a 48k ceiling previously mentioned)

I just realised the speakers caps at 96kHz, but yes that would explain it, as thats the next best option.

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Apr 15, 2024

I just realised the speakers caps at 96kHz

ok, it explains a lot.
Still catching the issue with 44/48.
With both "Bit depth switching" enabled and disabled.
Screenshot 2024-04-15 at 6 29 04 PM
Screenshot 2024-04-15 at 6 28 02 PM
Update:
Clandestina (feat. Emma Peters) [Cocaina Remix] - this one has a really strange behavior. It starts with 44.1 then jumps to 48, and then if I change timing (aka rewind) e.g. 1:30 -> 2:50 it shows again 44.1

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
question Further information is requested
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants