Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Two host lines for each hop (regression between 0.92 and 0.95?) #499

Open
Daniel15 opened this issue Jan 3, 2024 · 0 comments
Open

Two host lines for each hop (regression between 0.92 and 0.95?) #499

Daniel15 opened this issue Jan 3, 2024 · 0 comments

Comments

@Daniel15
Copy link

Daniel15 commented Jan 3, 2024

I'm using mtr with a command like this:

mtr --no-dns --raw --report-cycles 100 example.com

mtr 0.92 (from the mtr-tiny Debian package) produces output like this:

IPv6:

x 0 33000
h 0 2605:4840:ffff::1
p 0 1409 33000
x 1 33001
h 1 2a12:3200:3000:173::1
p 1 365 33001
x 2 33002
h 2 2001:418:0:5000::6ec
p 2 1464 33002
x 3 33003
h 3 2001:728:0:2000::1c6
p 3 807 33003
x 4 33004
h 4 2001:728:0:2000::1ba
p 4 20050 33004
x 5 33005
h 5 2001:728:0:2000::171
p 5 29611 33005
x 6 33006
h 6 2001:418:0:2000::252
p 6 96138 33006
x 7 33007
h 7 2001:418:0:2000::22a
p 7 96671 33007
x 8 33008
h 8 2001:418:0:5000::471
p 8 97392 33008
x 9 33009
h 9 2606:2800:4262:f::6
p 9 97827 33009
x 10 33010
h 10 2606:2800:220:1:248:1893:25c8:1946
p 10 98336 33010
x 11 33011
h 11 2606:2800:220:1:248:1893:25c8:1946
p 11 98076 33011
x 0 33012
p 0 4130 33012
x 1 33013
p 1 3549 33013
x 2 33014
p 2 1557 33014
x 3 33015
p 3 835 33015
x 4 33016
p 4 20261 33016
x 5 33017
p 5 25145 33017
x 6 33018
x 7 33019
...

IPv4:

x 0 33000
h 0 45.91.94.1
p 0 42773 33000
x 1 33001
h 1 84.17.33.66
p 1 545 33001
x 2 33002
x 3 33003
h 3 154.54.58.5
p 3 6586 33003
x 4 33004
h 4 154.54.36.53
p 4 12134 33004
x 5 33005
h 5 130.117.0.121
p 5 18843 33005
x 6 33006
h 6 154.54.56.93
p 6 25551 33006
x 7 33007
h 7 154.54.82.34
p 7 87929 33007
x 8 33008
x 9 33009
h 8 38.88.15.34
p 8 101301 33008
x 10 33010
h 9 152.195.233.131
p 9 112172 33009
h 10 93.184.216.34
p 10 87370 33010
x 11 33011
h 11 93.184.216.34
p 11 87378 33011
x 0 33012
p 0 22427 33012
x 1 33013
p 1 292 33013
x 2 33014
x 3 33015
p 3 10683 33015
x 4 33016
x 5 33017
p 4 97284 33016
p 5 19058 33017
x 6 33018
p 6 58575 33018
x 7 33019
x 8 33020
p 7 87864 33019
x 9 33021
p 8 88045 33020
x 10 33022
p 9 120326 33021
p 10 87388 33022
x 0 33023
p 0 19984 33023
x 1 33024
p 1 366 33024
x 2 33025
...

However, mtr 0.95 produces output like this:

x 0 33000
h 0 2607:f7a0:a::1
h 0 2607:f7a0:a::1
p 0 11105 33000
x 1 33001
h 1 2a02:6ea0:8:1120:5033::1
h 1 2a02:6ea0:8:1120:5033::1
p 1 313 33001
x 2 33002
x 3 33003
h 3 2001:550:2:18::e9:2
h 3 2001:550:2:18::e9:2
p 3 1199 33003
x 4 33004
h 4 2606:2800:4063:f::2
h 4 2606:2800:4063:f::2
p 4 4621 33004
x 5 33005
h 5 2606:2800:220:1:248:1893:25c8:1946
h 5 2606:2800:220:1:248:1893:25c8:1946
p 5 507 33005
x 6 33006
h 6 2606:2800:220:1:248:1893:25c8:1946
h 6 2606:2800:220:1:248:1893:25c8:1946
p 6 404 33006
x 0 33007
p 0 41218 33007
x 1 33008
p 1 369 33008
x 2 33009
x 3 33010
p 3 1199 33010
x 4 33011
p 4 1130 33011
x 5 33012
p 5 395 33012
x 0 33013
p 0 4095 33013
x 1 33014
p 1 332 33014
x 2 33015
h 2 2001:550:2:18::152:1
h 2 2001:550:2:18::152:1
p 2 949 33015
x 3 33016
p 3 4187 33016
x 4 33017
p 4 1435 33017
x 5 33018
p 5 404 33018
x 0 33019
p 0 2362 33019
x 1 33020
p 1 296 33020
x 2 33021
p 2 1119 33021
x 3 33022
p 3 1347 33022
x 4 33023
p 4 1653 33023
...

IPv4:

x 0 33000
h 0 31.220.30.1
h 0 31.220.30.1
p 0 22831 33000
x 1 33001
h 1 156.146.32.144
h 1 156.146.32.144
p 1 374 33001
x 2 33002
h 2 38.142.33.185
h 2 38.142.33.185
p 2 982 33002
x 3 33003
h 3 38.104.83.194
h 3 38.104.83.194
p 3 1175 33003
x 4 33004
h 4 152.195.77.129
h 4 152.195.77.129
p 4 16489 33004
x 5 33005
h 5 93.184.216.34
h 5 93.184.216.34
p 5 383 33005
x 6 33006
h 6 93.184.216.34
h 6 93.184.216.34
p 6 377 33006
x 0 33007
p 0 31076 33007
x 1 33008
p 1 374 33008
x 2 33009
p 2 950 33009
x 3 33010
p 3 1292 33010
x 4 33011
p 4 20470 33011
...

The host (h) line for each hop appears twice.

Is this intentional? I don't see any recent changes to the FORMATS file.

@Daniel15 Daniel15 changed the title Multiple host lines Two host lines for each hop (regression between 0.92 and 0.95?) Jan 3, 2024
Daniel15 added a commit to Daniel15/dnstools that referenced this issue Jan 3, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant