You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
mỉ is currently marked as collective. Given the current definition, it is ambiguous how this is supposed to be interpreted. It could mean either "___ is collectively named X" or "___ is everything that is named X". But neither of these are generally what one wants.
For example, consider the official example mỉ sảrā ní da. It is claimed to mean "this is Sarah", but with collective mỉ, it can only mean either "these things are collectively named Sarah" or "these things are everything in the universe of discourse that is named Sarah". Only if mỉ is distributive do we get the intended reading.
One may argue that you sometimes want to name things collectively—such as "the Smiths" (a family named Smith). This would still be possible with a distributive mỉ by manually specifying collectivity with mẻ, so making mỉ distributive would not cause us to lose any expressive power.
mỉ
is currently marked as collective. Given the current definition, it is ambiguous how this is supposed to be interpreted. It could mean either "___ is collectively named X" or "___ is everything that is named X". But neither of these are generally what one wants.For example, consider the official example
mỉ sảrā ní da
. It is claimed to mean "this is Sarah", but with collectivemỉ
, it can only mean either "these things are collectively named Sarah" or "these things are everything in the universe of discourse that is named Sarah". Only ifmỉ
is distributive do we get the intended reading.One may argue that you sometimes want to name things collectively—such as "the Smiths" (a family named Smith). This would still be possible with a distributive
mỉ
by manually specifying collectivity withmẻ
, so makingmỉ
distributive would not cause us to lose any expressive power.See the discussion in chat.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: