diff --git a/lib/logmatcher.c b/lib/logmatcher.c
index 8f7140aa704..26481df207c 100644
--- a/lib/logmatcher.c
+++ b/lib/logmatcher.c
@@ -384,6 +384,7 @@ typedef struct _LogMatcherPcreMatchResult
   const gchar *source_value;
   gssize source_value_len;
   pcre2_match_data *match_data;
+  gboolean source_handles_value_changed;
 } LogMatcherPcreMatchResult;
 
 static inline void
@@ -404,7 +405,8 @@ log_matcher_pcre_re_feed_value(LogMatcherPcreRe *self, LogMessage *msg,
 {
   gboolean indirect = result->source_handle != LM_V_NONE &&
                       log_msg_is_handle_settable_with_an_indirect_value(target_handle) &&
-                      log_msg_is_handle_referencable_from_an_indirect_value(result->source_handle);
+                      log_msg_is_handle_referencable_from_an_indirect_value(result->source_handle) &&
+                      !result->source_handles_value_changed;
 
   if (target_handle == result->source_handle)
     {
@@ -416,6 +418,8 @@ log_matcher_pcre_re_feed_value(LogMatcherPcreRe *self, LogMessage *msg,
        * make it less appearent, this is not always the case: it does not
        * happen if the new value does not fit the old NVEntry).  */
       log_matcher_pcre_re_save_source_value_to_avoid_clobbering(result);
+      result->source_handles_value_changed = TRUE;
+      indirect = FALSE;
     }
 
   if (indirect)
@@ -509,6 +513,7 @@ log_matcher_pcre_re_match(LogMatcher *s, LogMessage *msg, gint value_handle, con
   result.source_value = value;
   result.source_value_len = value_len;
   result.source_handle = value_handle;
+  result.source_handles_value_changed = FALSE;
 
   rc = pcre2_match(self->pattern,
                    (PCRE2_SPTR) result.source_value,
diff --git a/lib/tests/test_matcher.c b/lib/tests/test_matcher.c
index 2b69f0de010..fae26809e88 100644
--- a/lib/tests/test_matcher.c
+++ b/lib/tests/test_matcher.c
@@ -448,6 +448,41 @@ Test(matcher, test_matcher_matches_against_buffers_are_captured_directly)
   log_msg_unref(msg);
 }
 
+Test(matcher, test_matcher_matches_are_captured_directly_if_source_handle_changes)
+{
+  LogMatcherOptions matcher_options;
+  LogMessage *msg;
+  gboolean result;
+
+  const gchar *input = "kiwi-wiki-kiki";
+
+  msg = create_empty_message();
+  log_msg_set_value_with_type(msg, LM_V_FILE_NAME, input, -1, LM_VT_STRING);
+
+  log_matcher_options_defaults(&matcher_options);
+  matcher_options.flags = LMF_STORE_MATCHES;
+  LogMatcher *m = log_matcher_pcre_re_new(&matcher_options);
+  log_matcher_compile(m, "^(?<A_foobar>kiwi)-(?<FILE_NAME>wiki)-(?<Z_barbaz>kiki)", NULL);
+
+  result = log_matcher_match(m, msg, LM_V_FILE_NAME, input, 14);
+  cr_assert(result);
+
+  assert_log_message_match_value(msg, 1, "kiwi");
+  assert_log_message_match_value(msg, 2, "wiki");
+  assert_log_message_match_value(msg, 3, "kiki");
+  assert_log_message_value_by_name(msg, "A_foobar", "kiwi");
+  assert_log_message_value_by_name(msg, "FILE_NAME", "wiki");
+  assert_log_message_value_by_name(msg, "Z_barbaz", "kiki");
+  assert_log_message_value_is_direct(msg, log_msg_get_value_handle("1"));
+  assert_log_message_value_is_direct(msg, log_msg_get_value_handle("2"));
+  assert_log_message_value_is_direct(msg, log_msg_get_value_handle("3"));
+  assert_log_message_value_is_direct(msg, log_msg_get_value_handle("A_foobar"));
+  assert_log_message_value_is_direct(msg, log_msg_get_value_handle("FILE_NAME"));
+  assert_log_message_value_is_direct(msg, log_msg_get_value_handle("Z_barbaz"));
+  log_matcher_unref(m);
+  log_msg_unref(msg);
+}
+
 Test(matcher, test_replace_works_correctly_if_capture_group_overwrites_the_input_in_a_match_variable)
 {
   gssize value_len;
diff --git a/news/bugfix-4759.md b/news/bugfix-4759.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000000..d1acb54c467
--- /dev/null
+++ b/news/bugfix-4759.md
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+`regexp-parser()`: Fixed a bug, which stored some values incorrectly if `${MESSAGE}` was changed with a capture group.