diff --git a/WHAT-WE-LEARNED.md b/WHAT-WE-LEARNED.md index cbddfaa..72a09ca 100644 --- a/WHAT-WE-LEARNED.md +++ b/WHAT-WE-LEARNED.md @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ Unless I'm missing something, there doesn't seem to be any warning when there is ## UI and Server functions don't really separate concerns -My first impression was that the UI function would be something like a "view" and the server would be a "controller", but for any kind of conditional display I need a `render.ui`, so that distinction breaks down quickly. +My first impression was that the UI function would be something like a "view" and the server would be a "controller", but for any kind of conditional display I need a `render.ui`, so that distinction breaks down quickly. Just maintaining a naming convention for these little bits of UI in the server gets to be a chore. It would be kludgy, but what if we could suply lambdas instead of names? ## Refactoring: values vs. reactive values @@ -63,6 +63,10 @@ I've had to tweak the CSS a few times: The different flavors of "Shiny" are a bit of nuissance when trying to find examples. The maturity of Shiny for R means that the vast majority of the examples are for R, even with Python in the search. It would be nice if the docs site remembered that I only want to look at docs for Core. +## It's easy to forget `return` + +This is simple, but I was still scratching my head for a while. While there are some cases where returning `None` is intended, is it more more likely to be an error? What if it raised a warning, and an explicit empty string could be returned if that's really what you want? + ## Shiny docs could have better formatting - https://shiny.posit.co/py/api/core/ui.layout_columns.html: bullet list not rendered correctly. diff --git a/dp_creator_ii/app/analysis_panel.py b/dp_creator_ii/app/analysis_panel.py index ab17b60..2a256da 100644 --- a/dp_creator_ii/app/analysis_panel.py +++ b/dp_creator_ii/app/analysis_panel.py @@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ from dp_creator_ii.app.components.inputs import log_slider from dp_creator_ii.app.components.column_module import column_ui, column_server from dp_creator_ii.utils.csv_helper import read_field_names -from dp_creator_ii.app.components.outputs import output_code_sample +from dp_creator_ii.app.components.outputs import output_code_sample, demo_tooltip from dp_creator_ii.utils.templates import make_privacy_loss_block @@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ def analysis_ui(): "the number of bins for the histogram, " "and its relative share of the privacy budget." ), + ui.output_ui("columns_checkbox_group_tooltip_ui"), ui.input_checkbox_group("columns_checkbox_group", None, []), ui.output_ui("columns_ui"), ui.markdown( @@ -25,6 +26,7 @@ def analysis_ui(): "Values above 1 will add less noise to the data, " "but have a greater risk of revealing individual data." ), + ui.output_ui("epsilon_tooltip_ui"), log_slider("log_epsilon_slider", 0.1, 10.0), ui.output_text("epsilon"), output_code_sample("Privacy Loss", "privacy_loss_python"), @@ -75,6 +77,17 @@ def _on_column_set_change(): column_ids_selected = input.columns_checkbox_group() clear_column_weights(column_ids_selected) + @render.ui + def columns_checkbox_group_tooltip_ui(): + return demo_tooltip( + is_demo, + """ + Not all columns need analysis. For this demo, just check + "class_year" and "grade". With more columns selected, + each column has a smaller share of the privacy budget. + """, + ) + @render.ui def columns_ui(): column_ids = input.columns_checkbox_group() @@ -86,6 +99,7 @@ def columns_ui(): epsilon=epsilon_calc(), set_column_weight=set_column_weight, get_weights_sum=get_weights_sum, + is_demo=is_demo, ) return [ [ @@ -103,6 +117,17 @@ def csv_fields_calc(): def csv_fields(): return csv_fields_calc() + @render.ui + def epsilon_tooltip_ui(): + return demo_tooltip( + is_demo, + """ + If you set epsilon above one, you'll see that the distribution + becomes less noisy, and the confidence intervals become smaller... + but increased accuracy risks revealing personal information. + """, + ) + @reactive.calc def epsilon_calc(): return pow(10, input.log_epsilon_slider()) diff --git a/dp_creator_ii/app/components/column_module.py b/dp_creator_ii/app/components/column_module.py index 7bc95d8..c27e51d 100644 --- a/dp_creator_ii/app/components/column_module.py +++ b/dp_creator_ii/app/components/column_module.py @@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ from dp_creator_ii.utils.dp_helper import make_confidence_accuracy_histogram from dp_creator_ii.app.components.plots import plot_histogram from dp_creator_ii.utils.templates import make_column_config_block -from dp_creator_ii.app.components.outputs import output_code_sample +from dp_creator_ii.app.components.outputs import output_code_sample, demo_tooltip @module.ui @@ -13,9 +13,12 @@ def column_ui(): # pragma: no cover width = "10em" # Just wide enough so the text isn't trucated. return ui.layout_columns( [ + ui.output_ui("bounds_tooltip_ui"), ui.input_numeric("min", "Min", 0, width=width), ui.input_numeric("max", "Max", 10, width=width), + ui.output_ui("bins_tooltip_ui"), ui.input_numeric("bins", "Bins", 10, width=width), + ui.output_ui("weight_tooltip_ui"), ui.input_select( "weight", "Weight", @@ -60,6 +63,7 @@ def column_server( epsilon, set_column_weight, get_weights_sum, + is_demo, ): # pragma: no cover @reactive.effect @reactive.event(input.weight) @@ -75,6 +79,44 @@ def column_config(): "weight": float(input.weight()), } + @render.ui + def bounds_tooltip_ui(): + return demo_tooltip( + is_demo, + """ + DP requires that we limit the sensitivity to the contributions + of any individual. To do this, we need an estimate of the lower + and upper bounds for each variable. We should not look at the + data when estimating the bounds! In this case, we could imagine + that "class year" would vary between 1 and 4, and we could limit + "grade" to values between 50 and 100. + """, + ) + + @render.ui + def bins_tooltip_ui(): + return demo_tooltip( + is_demo, + """ + Different statistics can be measured with DP. + This tool provides a histogram. If you increase the number of bins, + you'll see that each individual bin becomes noisier to provide + the same overall privacy guarantee. For this example, give + "class_year" 4 bins and "grade" 5 bins. + """, + ) + + @render.ui + def weight_tooltip_ui(): + return demo_tooltip( + is_demo, + """ + You have a finite privacy budget, but you can choose + how to allocate it. For simplicity, we limit the options here, + but when using the library you can fine tune this. + """, + ) + @render.code def column_code(): config = column_config()