coll/xhc not sessions friendly

[hppritcha]

If I run the ompi-tests/ibm/sessions/sessions_init_twice.c test with the xhc module enabled there's a segfault in the second initialization of MPI:

 0 0x0000000000012cf0 __funlockfile()  :0
 1 0x00000000000cbe35 __strlen_avx2()  :0
 2 0x000000000009f682 __GI___strdup()  :0
 3 0x00000000001ff74c mca_coll_xhc_read_op_config()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/mca/coll/xhc/coll_xhc.c:390
 4 0x0000000000206ac1 mca_coll_xhc_module_enable()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/mca/coll/xhc/coll_xhc_module.c:209
 5 0x0000000000170240 mca_coll_base_comm_select()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/mca/coll/base/coll_base_comm_select.c:257
 6 0x00000000000757e7 ompi_comm_activate_complete()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/communicator/comm_cid.c:912
 7 0x0000000000076645 ompi_comm_activate_nb_complete()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/communicator/comm_cid.c:1108
 8 0x0000000000079d26 ompi_comm_request_progress()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/communicator/comm_request.c:154
 9 0x0000000000027115 opal_progress()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/opal/runtime/opal_progress.c:224
10 0x0000000000072d48 ompi_request_wait_completion()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/../ompi/request/request.h:493
11 0x0000000000075ff7 ompi_comm_activate()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/communicator/comm_cid.c:1042
12 0x000000000006f255 ompi_comm_create_from_group()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/communicator/comm.c:1595
13 0x00000000000db42d PMPI_Comm_create_from_group()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-er2/ompi/mpi/c/comm_create_from_group.c:106
14 0x00000000004011d2 main()  /home/hpritchard/ompi-tests/ibm/sessions/sessions_init_twice.c:135
15 0x000000000003ad85 __libc_start_main()  ???:0
16 0x0000000000400c4e _start()  ???:0

[jsquyres]

FYI: @gkatev

[gkatev]

Thanks for the ping, I'll check it out

[gkatev]

I'm having trouble reproducing this, can you tell me more about your environment?

$ mpirun -n 2 --mca coll basic,libnbc,xhc --mca coll_xhc_priority 100 ./sessions_init_twice
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
Finished first finalize
Finished first finalize
Starting second init
Starting second init
Finished second init
Finished second init
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()
read_op_config()

(I'm on the latest main, 0bccfcd)

[gkatev]

By only looking at the code, a segfault at that strdup means that either something's wrong with the info cstring, or with op_mca.hierarchy (= mca_coll_xhc_component.op_mca[colltype]).

ompi/ompi/mca/coll/xhc/coll_xhc.c

Lines 390 to 391 in 0bccfcd

	config->hierarchy_string = strdup(info_flag ?
	info_val->string : op_mca.hierarchy);

The path that involves the info stuff shouldn't be chosen by default. (I don't imagine you are setting an ompi_comm_coll_xhc_* info key somewhere??)

mca_coll_xhc_component.op_mca[].hierarchy is set in coll_xhc_component.c, either in the initialization of the global mca_coll_xhc_component, or in one of two mca_base_component_var_register() calls.

[hppritcha]

i'll do some more debugging... i'm not setting any special mca params for xhc.

[hppritcha]

okay i see what's going on. The strings in the mca_coll_xhc_component are being registered with the MCA system.
across a session_finalize/session_init - and the app has no other sessions (including MPI_Init generated one - the MCA system is torn down in the finalize and parameters registered as MCA_BASE_VAR_TYPE_STRING types are freed.

I added some debug output to xhc_register that shows this:

for op 0 hierarchy 0x61b5e0 chunk_size 0x61c020 cico_max 256
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61b5e0 chunk_size 0x61c020 cico_max 256
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61b5e0 chunk_size 0x61c020 cico_max 256
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61bd30 chunk_size 0x151d84d85f7e cico_max 0
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61bd30 chunk_size 0x151d84d85f7e cico_max 0
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x15361fb64f7e cico_max 0
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x15361fb64f7e cico_max 0
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x15361fb64f7e cico_max 0
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x14f04c08cf7e cico_max 0
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x14f04c08cf7e cico_max 0
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x14f04c08cf7e cico_max 0
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61b660 chunk_size 0x61c0a0 cico_max 256
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x147d1db64f7e cico_max 0
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x147d1db64f7e cico_max 0
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61bdb0 chunk_size 0x147d1db64f7e cico_max 0
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c0c0 chunk_size 0x61ccd0 cico_max 4096
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61bd30 chunk_size 0x151d84d85f7e cico_max 0
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c040 chunk_size 0x61cc50 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c040 chunk_size 0x61cc50 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c040 chunk_size 0x61cc50 cico_max 4096
for op 0 hierarchy 0x61c300 chunk_size 0x61ce60 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c300 chunk_size 0x61ce60 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c300 chunk_size 0x61ce60 cico_max 4096
for op 1 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
for op 2 hierarchy 0x61c380 chunk_size 0x61cee0 cico_max 4096
Finished first finalize
Finished first finalize
Finished first finalize
Finished first finalize
Starting second init
Starting second init
Starting second init
Starting second init
running xhc_register
running xhc_register - opal smsc thing returns -13
ran xhc_register
running xhc_register
running xhc_register - opal smsc thing returns -13
ran xhc_register
running xhc_register
running xhc_register - opal smsc thing returns -13
ran xhc_register
running xhc_register
running xhc_register - opal smsc thing returns -13
ran xhc_register
Finished second init
Finished second init
Finished second init
Finished second init
for op 0 hierarchy (nil) chunk_size (nil) cico_max 256
for op 0 hierarchy (nil) chunk_size (nil) cico_max 256

If one builds Open MPI with the --enable-mca-dso option this problem doesn't occur because the xhc.so module is dlopened again in the second session init so the values used in initializing mca_coll_xhc_component appear again.