Some icons are randomly smaller than others

[simoheinonen]

Describe the bug

Some icons are smaller than others when doing cmd+tab. Happens pretty consistently but not all the time so not sure if this a bug or some kind of feature I don't understand.

Screenshots / video

Steps to reproduce the bug

macOS Monterey 12.0
AltTab 6.28.0

[lwouis]

I set my preferences to the same values you show on the screenshot, and it works correctly for me.

It seems like a bug in the layout logic. The layout logic is very complex, as you can see from the available options offered to customize. I'm noticing that you have the window titles set to 10px here, though it doesn't show, because you set the min width in row to 0% for instance.

I'm afraid I can't offer much for now. I think I approached with too much open-ness when I made the layout system. I'm hoping it can be remade to focus on the common use cases like yours (big app icons, no thumbnail, no title). Most people (rightfully) don't understand how the various parameters interact.

So short-term, please try to play with the options. Maybe some variation will be more stable / not have the issue. More long-term, proper solution will happen we we rework the appearance preferences, and the layout system.

I'll close this ticket for now as I consider it will be subsumed by tickets such as #351

[simoheinonen]

Making "Window min width in row" over 0% fixed it for me!

[lwouis]

@simoheinonen thank you for reporting the workaround which worked for you! I will push a quick short-term fix to avoid users being able to set min/max width to 0%. I'm not sure 0% ever makes sense, so forcing at least 1% should avoid this situation, while being a quick workaround to implement in the short-term before more serious reworks.