PBS wiki page

[taxmeifyoucan]

Proposer builder separation is necessary to understand the current state of Ethereum protocol and discussions around it. PBS should be documented in the wiki, here is a rough outline on what should be included:

• Quick intro, what the page will cover
• Insight into consensus layer
  • Explaining role of the builder
  • Explain role of the proposal
• Current state
  • default behavior
  • PBS and relationship of relays, builders and validators
  • mevboost, documenting what is it, how it works
  • issues stemming from this (security, third party dependency, censorship etc)
• Proposed solutions, current R&D
  • ePBS, inclusion lists, PEPC, etc
• Collection of resources
  • all hackmds, ethresearch posts and related articles, videos, papers you stumble upon

[raxhvl]

This is pretty new to me. Do you know where in the sidebar should this come? I believe Ynyesto and Kira are collaborating on this. I'll pickup something else.

[shyam-patel-kira]

I'm creating WIP PR for this one, it is open for collaboration

[shyam-patel-kira]

Creating a checklist here, for tracking purposes

• Quick intro, what the page will cover
• Insight into consensus layer
  • Explaining role of the builder
  • Explain role of the proposal
• Current state
  • default behavior
  • PBS and relationship of relays, builders and validators
  • mevboost, documenting what is it, how it works
  • issues stemming from this (security, third party dependency, censorship etc)
• Proposed solutions, current R&D
  • ePBS
  • 2-slot PBS
  • PEPC
  • Execution Tickets
  • inclusion lists
• Collection of resources
  • all hackmds, ethresearch posts and related articles, videos, papers you stumble upon

[shyam-patel-kira]

I'm currently writing on mev-boost and ePBS. Adding the comment to avoid confusion, promote collaborative effort

[thogiti]

I am working on ePBS.

https://github.com/thogiti/protocol-studies/blob/pbs/docs/wiki/research/PBS/ePBS.md

PR:
#115

[thogiti]

May I suggest to remove ePBS solutions section from the PBS.md page.

I am working on a detailed ePBS page at #118.

[taxmeifyoucan]

ePBS deserves its own page for sure but it still should be mentioned and linked in the main pbs doc. Just a high level overview with link to details in the separate page

[shyam-patel-kira]

Sorry for the late update from my side. I've update my PR with current changes and also included link to future ePBS entry. I'm not able to request a review though, so tagging you here @taxmeifyoucan

[gorondan]

I'm working on PEPC and ETs. Very interested in roles separation in general, especially on enshrined Operator-Delegator Separation (in research).

ePBS deserves its own page for sure but it still should be mentioned and linked in the main pbs doc. Just a high level overview with link to details in the separate page

With ePBS, PEPC, Execution Tickets and Rainbow staking being in active research, the vectors seem to be pointing towards an enshrining of roles separation era to come. wdyt guys? should we dedicate a section on protocol Roles Separation, curated by EPF sg?

[thogiti]

Hi @gorondan.

I have briefly covered PEPC as a solution to ePBS in my PR at 3aac3f6.

Here is the link to the PEPC section: https://github.com/thogiti/protocol-studies/blob/pbs/docs/wiki/research/PBS/ePBS.md#pepc-protocol-enforced-proposer-commitments

But, I think, PEPC and ET definitely deserve their own page.

[thogiti]

Hi @shyam-patel-kira @arynyestos

I think my PR on ePBS #115 is showing some conflicts on pbs.md. Can you please check your latest changes to pbs.md?

Can you please let me know what is your latest commit hash for pbs.md?

I think the pbs.md merge action is waiting for resolving these content conflict.