diff --git a/src/cohesion/helpers.js b/src/cohesion/helpers.js
index c66c9ae55..de0c30720 100644
--- a/src/cohesion/helpers.js
+++ b/src/cohesion/helpers.js
@@ -9,6 +9,11 @@ export const getCorrelationID = () => {
   const COOKIE_NAME = 'tglr_correlation_id';
   const PARAM_NAME = 'correlationId';
 
+  // If the tagular correlation ID cookie was set before we added the change to
+  // specify the domain, it was automatically added to the current domain.
+  // Always delete the cookie with the current domain
+  new Cookies().remove(COOKIE_NAME, { domain: 'payment.edx.org', path: '/' });
+
   function getDomain() {
     const { hostname } = window.location;
     const parts = hostname.split('.');
@@ -29,7 +34,7 @@ export const getCorrelationID = () => {
 
   const expirationDate = new Date();
   expirationDate.setMinutes(expirationDate.getMinutes() + 30); // 30 mins expiration from now
-  new Cookies().set(COOKIE_NAME, paramId, { expires: expirationDate, domain: `.${getDomain()}` });
+  new Cookies().set(COOKIE_NAME, paramId, { expires: expirationDate, domain: `.${getDomain()}`, path: '/' });
 
   return paramId;
 };