diff --git a/mod/Jailbreak.Warden/Selection/WardenSelectionBehavior.cs b/mod/Jailbreak.Warden/Selection/WardenSelectionBehavior.cs
index 20759e1d..a2a70ce2 100644
--- a/mod/Jailbreak.Warden/Selection/WardenSelectionBehavior.cs
+++ b/mod/Jailbreak.Warden/Selection/WardenSelectionBehavior.cs
@@ -111,6 +111,7 @@ public void ScheduleChooseWarden(float time = 7.0f) {
   ///   Timer callback that states it's time to choose the warden.
   /// </summary>
   protected void OnChooseWarden() {
+    guaranteedWarden.Clear();
     if (warden.HasWarden) return;
     var eligible = Utilities.GetPlayers()
      .Where(player => player.PawnIsAlive)