diff --git a/lib/DependencyResolver.ts b/lib/DependencyResolver.ts
index 4dcdc41..efd1f65 100644
--- a/lib/DependencyResolver.ts
+++ b/lib/DependencyResolver.ts
@@ -234,10 +234,8 @@ export class DependencyResolver {
               }. Using that`
             )
             dependency.targetModule = existingModule
-          } else if (!this._store.hasPuppetfileRequirementWithTargetModule(dependency.targetModule.getSlug())) {
-            this._log.debug(
-              `Dependency ${dependency.targetModule.getSlug()} is not already a base Puppetfile requirement, adding it.`
-            )
+          } else {
+            this._log.debug(`Adding requirement for dependency to ${dependency.targetModule.getSlug()}`)
             this._store.addRequirement(
               new Requirement()
                 .withSource(RequirementSource.Dependency)
@@ -245,11 +243,6 @@ export class DependencyResolver {
                 .withTargetModule(dependency.targetModule)
                 .withDependencyRange(dependency.dependencyRange)
             )
-          } else if (
-            this._store.hasPuppetfileRequirementWithTargetModule(dependency.targetModule.getSlug()) &&
-            !this._ignoreList.some((slug) => slug === dependency.targetModule?.getSlug())
-          ) {
-            throw new NoVersionFoundError(dependency)
           }
         }
       }
diff --git a/test/dependency.resolver.test.ts b/test/dependency.resolver.test.ts
index 0f2362c..b5f684c 100644
--- a/test/dependency.resolver.test.ts
+++ b/test/dependency.resolver.test.ts
@@ -66,6 +66,12 @@ describe('The dependency resolver', function () {
         ],
       },
     })
+    sb.get('/v3/releases/test-wrongdepc-1.2.2').setResponseBody({
+      slug: 'test-defaultdependency',
+      metadata: {
+        dependencies: [],
+      },
+    })
     sb.get('/v3/releases/test-wrongdepc-1.2.3').setResponseBody({
       slug: 'test-defaultdependency',
       metadata: {
@@ -124,6 +130,9 @@ describe('The dependency resolver', function () {
         {
           version: '1.2.3',
         },
+        {
+          version: '1.2.2',
+        },
       ],
     })
     sb.get('/v3/modules/test-deprecated').setResponseBody({
@@ -185,6 +194,25 @@ mod 'test-dependency', '1.2.4'
     expect(subject.dependentModules[0].version).toEqual('1.2.5')
   })
 
+  it('should create a valid puppetfile when a dependency is in the Puppetfile', async () => {
+    const subject = await new DependencyResolver()
+      .withPuppetFile(
+        await new PuppetFile().fromText(`
+forge 'http://localhost:${sb.getPort()}'
+
+mod 'test-default', '1.2.3'
+mod 'test-defaultdependency', '1.2.5'
+    `)
+      )
+      .resolve()
+    expect(subject.modules).toHaveLength(2)
+    expect(subject.modules[0].getSlug()).toEqual('test-default')
+    expect(subject.modules[0].version).toEqual('1.2.3')
+    expect(subject.modules[1].getSlug()).toEqual('test-defaultdependency')
+    expect(subject.modules[1].version).toEqual('1.2.5')
+    expect(subject.dependentModules).toHaveLength(0)
+  })
+
   it('should hide items from the puppetfile', async () => {
     const subject = await new DependencyResolver()
       .withPuppetFile(
@@ -284,7 +312,7 @@ mod 'test-deprecated', '1.2.3'
 forge 'http://localhost:${sb.getPort()}'
 
 mod 'test-wrongdepa', '1.2.3'
-mod 'test-wrongdepc', '1.2.3'
+mod 'test-wrongdepc', '1.2.2'
     `)
     )