Breakage with m2-git

[h-vetinari]

Aside from losing tags and branch heads in places like git log (see discussion post-merge in #277), I'm now running into another error:

git.exc.GitCommandError: Cmd('git') failed due to: exit code(128)
  cmdline: git rm --cached -- ci_support\upload_or_check_non_existence.py
  stderr: 'fatal: pathspec 'ci_support\upload_or_check_non_existence.py' did not match any files'

There's a missing period before "ci_support"; no idea though where the processing goes wrong.

Downgrading smithy to the _0 build of smithy 3.36.0 didn't fix things (neither the error, nor the tag visibility), but that didn't get rid of the new m2-* packages that _1 had dragged in (and conda install --revision <X> didn't resolve for 15min, so I gave up). However, after recreating the environment from scratch, the rerender works again. So it's the mere presence of some of the following libs that breaks things.

2024-05-23 22:10:20  (rev 35)
     conda-smithy  {3.36.0 (conda-forge/noarch) -> 3.36.0 (conda-forge/noarch)}
    +m2-bash-4.3.042 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-ca-certificates-20150426 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-coreutils-8.25 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-curl-7.47.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-db-5.3.28 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-expat-2.1.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-findutils-4.6.0 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-gcc-libs-5.3.0 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-gdbm-1.11 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-git-2.8.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-gmp-6.1.0 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-gzip-1.7 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-heimdal-1.5.3 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-heimdal-libs-1.5.3 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-icu-56.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-info-6.0 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-less-481 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libcrypt-1.3 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libcurl-7.47.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libdb-5.3.28 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libedit-3.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libexpat-2.1.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libffi-3.2.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libgdbm-1.11 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libiconv-1.14 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libidn-1.32 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libintl-0.19.7 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libmetalink-0.1.2 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libopenssl-1.0.2.g (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libp11-kit-0.23.2 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libpcre-8.38 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libreadline-6.3.008 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libsqlite-3.10.0.0 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libssh2-1.6.0 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-libtasn1-4.7 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-ncurses-6.0.20160220 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-openssh-7.1p2 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-openssl-1.0.2.g (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-p11-kit-0.23.2 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-5.22.1 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-authen-sasl-2.16 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-convert-binhex-1.123 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-encode-locale-1.04 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-error-0.17024 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-file-listing-6.04 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-html-parser-3.71 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-html-tagset-3.20 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-http-cookies-6.01 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-http-daemon-6.01 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-http-date-6.02 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-http-message-6.06 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-http-negotiate-6.01 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-io-socket-ssl-2.016 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-io-stringy-2.111 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-libwww-6.13 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-lwp-mediatypes-6.02 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-mailtools-2.14 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-mime-tools-5.506 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-net-http-6.09 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-net-smtp-ssl-1.02 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-net-ssleay-1.72 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-termreadkey-2.33 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-timedate-2.30 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-uri-1.68 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-perl-www-robotrules-6.02 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-sed-4.2.2 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-vim-7.4.1721 (conda-forge/win-64)
    +m2-zlib-1.2.8 (conda-forge/win-64)

Long-term, I'd like to have a __git package (not necessarily virtual, just something that tells the resolver it's already available locally), which allows me not to drag in the huge git updates all the time.

[jakirkham]

Should we just drop the git package on Windows altogether?

It's unfortunate we don't have a better story for git on Windows

[jakirkham]

Seeing a +1 went ahead and made a PR ( #291 ) to drop git on Windows

Please let me know what you think

Happy to discuss other options as well