From 07c348d05a8f7f9564ed2246e00aec7a475978a7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Akihiro Suda <akihiro.suda.cz@hco.ntt.co.jp>
Date: Tue, 4 Jun 2024 21:39:28 +0900
Subject: [PATCH] self-assessment: add Lima

Add self-assessment of [Lima](https://lima-vm.io) (CNCF Sandbox)

Signed-off-by: Akihiro Suda <akihiro.suda.cz@hco.ntt.co.jp>
---
 .../projects/lima/self-assessment.md          | 371 ++++++++++++++++++
 1 file changed, 371 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 community/assessments/projects/lima/self-assessment.md

diff --git a/community/assessments/projects/lima/self-assessment.md b/community/assessments/projects/lima/self-assessment.md
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..1430ba889
--- /dev/null
+++ b/community/assessments/projects/lima/self-assessment.md
@@ -0,0 +1,371 @@
+<!-- cSpell:ignore containerd nerdctl contai limactl sshfs vmnet govulncheck xbar COBIT CodeQL GHSA Flibber Flocker -->
+# Self-assessment
+<!--
+Template: https://github.com/cncf/tag-security/blob/50d5f61d7f9dfb88dd3639a1579304f504eaedd3/community/assessments/guide/self-assessment.md
+(2024-06-22)
+-->
+
+<!--
+The Self-assessment is the initial document for projects to begin thinking about the
+security of the project, determining gaps in their security, and preparing any security
+documentation for their users. This document is ideal for projects currently in the
+CNCF **sandbox** as well as projects that are looking to receive a joint assessment and
+currently in CNCF **incubation**.
+
+For a detailed guide with step-by-step discussion and examples, check out the free
+Express Learning course provided by Linux Foundation Training & Certification:
+[Security Assessments for Open Source Projects](https://training.linuxfoundation.org/express-learning/security-self-assessments-for-open-source-projects-lfel1005/).
+-->
+
+# Self-assessment outline
+
+## Table of contents
+
+* [Metadata](#metadata)
+  * [Security links](#security-links)
+* [Overview](#overview)
+  * [Actors](#actors)
+  * [Actions](#actions)
+  * [Background](#background)
+  * [Goals](#goals)
+  * [Non-goals](#non-goals)
+* [Self-assessment use](#self-assessment-use)
+* [Security functions and features](#security-functions-and-features)
+* [Project compliance](#project-compliance)
+* [Secure development practices](#secure-development-practices)
+* [Security issue resolution](#security-issue-resolution)
+* [Appendix](#appendix)
+
+## Metadata
+
+<!--
+A table at the top for quick reference information, later used for indexing.
+-->
+
+|||
+| -- | -- |
+| Assessment Stage | Incomplete |
+| Software | <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima> |
+| Security Provider | No |
+| Languages | Go  |
+| SBOM | `go.mod` and `go.sum` contain the dependency information |
+
+### Security links
+
+<!--
+Provide the list of links to existing security documentation for the project. You may
+use the table below as an example:
+-->
+
+| Doc | url |
+| -- | -- |
+| Security file | <https://github.com/lima-vm/.github/blob/main/SECURITY.md> |
+| Default and optional configs | <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/blob/master/templates/default.yaml> |
+
+## Overview
+
+<!--
+One or two sentences describing the project -- something memorable and accurate
+that distinguishes your project to quickly orient readers who may be assessing
+multiple projects.
+-->
+
+[Lima](https://lima-vm.io/) launches Linux virtual machines with automatic file sharing and port forwarding (similar to WSL2).
+
+The original goal of Lima was to promote [containerd](https://containerd.io) including [nerdctl (contaiNERD ctl)](https://github.com/containerd/nerdctl)
+to Mac users, but Lima can be used for non-container applications as well.
+
+### Background
+
+<!--
+Provide information for reviewers who may not be familiar with your project's
+domain or problem area.
+-->
+
+A typical usage of Lima is like:
+
+```bash
+# Install
+brew install lima
+
+# Start the VM with the default template
+limactl start
+
+# Launch nerdctl (contaiNERD CTL) via Lima
+lima nerdctl run --rm hello-world
+```
+
+Lima uses YAML files to define VM templates.
+See <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/tree/master/templates> for the examples of the templates.
+
+A malicious template may break host OS via host filesystem mounts.
+It is users's responsibility to avoid using malicious templates.
+
+### Actors
+<!--
+These are the individual parts of your system that interact to provide the
+desired functionality.  Actors only need to be separate, if they are isolated
+in some way.  For example, if a service has a database and a front-end API, but
+if a vulnerability in either one would compromise the other, then the distinction
+between the database and front-end is not relevant.
+
+The means by which actors are isolated should also be described, as this is often
+what prevents an attacker from moving laterally after a compromise.
+-->
+
+* `limactl` CLI: the CLI provides CRUD operations for VM instances.
+  The CLI does not need the root privilege on the host OS.
+  A template file can be specified on creating an instance as follows:
+
+```bash
+# Built-in template
+limactl create template://docker
+
+# Local path
+limactl create /usr/local/share/lima/templates/fedora.yaml
+
+# HTTPS URL (use with a caution)
+limactl create https://raw.githubusercontent.com/lima-vm/lima/master/templates/alpine.yaml
+```
+
+* `lima` CLI: an alias of `limactl shell`, for logging into the guest OS.
+
+* VM drivers: the following virtual machine drivers are supported (no root privilege is needed):
+  * QEMU
+  * Apple Virtualization.framework (for macOS hosts)
+  * WSL2 (for Windows hosts)
+
+* SSH:
+  Lima generates an SSH key-pair and configure the guest OS so that the `lima` CLI (alias of `limactl shell`)
+  can login to the guest OS.
+  The SSH port is bound to the localhost of the host OS.
+
+* Port forwarder:
+  localhost ports of the guest OS are forwarded to the localhost of the host OS.
+  These forwarded ports are not exposed to non-localhost by default, but this behavior is customizable.
+
+* (Optional) SFTP:
+  When the filesystem mount type is configured to `reverse-sshfs` in a VM template,
+  Lima launches an SFTP server process on the host and associate its stream to
+  the SSH process so that the guest OS can mount the host filesystem.
+  The SFTP server process is launched as a non-root user.
+
+* (Optional) `socket_vmnet` daemon:
+  When the network type is set to `lima:shared` in a VM template,
+  Lima launches a [`socket_vmnet`](https://github.com/lima-vm/socket_vmnet) daemon with `sudo`
+  so as to enable enhanced networking mode, e.g., publish the VM's IP address to the physical network.
+
+### Actions
+<!--
+These are the steps that a project performs in order to provide some service
+or functionality.  These steps are performed by different actors in the system.
+Note, that an action need not be overly descriptive at the function call level.
+It is sufficient to focus on the security checks performed, use of sensitive
+data, and interactions between actors to perform an action.
+
+For example, the access server receives the client request, checks the format,
+validates that the request corresponds to a file the client is authorized to
+access, and then returns a token to the client.  The client then transmits that
+token to the file server, which, after confirming its validity, returns the file.
+-->
+
+* `limactl create`: the CLI receives a template file via the argument,
+  and populates the disk image for the instance.
+
+* `limactl start`: the CLI launches the instance using the specified VM driver,
+  and sets up port forwarding and filesystem mounts.
+  This action does not need the root privilege on the host.
+  When the network mode is set to `lima:shared`, the CLI launches the `socket_vmnet` daemon with `sudo`.
+  The `sudoers` file for this operation can be generated with the `limactl sudoers` command.
+
+* `limactl sudoers`: the CLI generates `/etc/sudoers.d/lima` file to allow running `socket_vmnet`.
+  Not needed for the default configuration.
+
+* `lima`, `limactl shell`: the CLI launches `ssh` to login to the VM instance.
+
+* `limactl stop`: the CLI stops the specified VM instance.
+
+* `limactl delete`: the CLI deletes the specified VM instance.
+
+### Goals
+<!--
+The intended goals of the projects including the security guarantees the project
+ is meant to provide (e.g., Flibble only allows parties with an authorization
+key to change data it stores).
+-->
+
+* No root privilege is needed for installing and running VM
+
+* When the root privilege is needed (i.e., `socket_vmnet`), the privileged operation is performed
+  in a separate process that is confined with the `sudoers` file
+
+* No port is published to non-localhost by default
+
+### Non-goals
+<!--
+Non-goals that a reasonable reader of the project’s literature could believe may
+be in scope (e.g., Flibble does not intend to stop a party with a key from storing
+an arbitrarily large amount of data, possibly incurring financial cost or overwhelming
+ the servers)
+-->
+
+* Tolerance to malicious template files is out of our goals.
+  An instance created from a malicious template may read and write host files,
+  depending on the host mounts specified in the template.
+
+## Self-assessment use
+
+<!--
+This self-assessment is created by the [project] team to perform an internal analysis of the
+project's security.  It is not intended to provide a security audit of [project], or
+function as an independent assessment or attestation of [project]'s security health.
+
+This document serves to provide [project] users with an initial understanding of
+[project]'s security, where to find existing security documentation, [project] plans for
+security, and general overview of [project] security practices, both for development of
+[project] as well as security of [project].
+
+This document provides the CNCF TAG-Security with an initial understanding of [project]
+to assist in a joint-assessment, necessary for projects under incubation.  Taken
+together, this document and the joint-assessment serve as a cornerstone for if and when
+[project] seeks graduation and is preparing for a security audit.
+-->
+
+This self-assessment is created by the Lima team to perform an internal analysis of the
+project's security.  It is not intended to provide a security audit of Lima, or
+function as an independent assessment or attestation of Lima's security health.
+
+This document serves to provide Lima users with an initial understanding of
+Lima's security, where to find existing security documentation, Lima plans for
+security, and general overview of Lima security practices, both for development of
+Lima as well as security of Lima.
+
+This document provides the CNCF TAG-Security with an initial understanding of Lima
+to assist in a joint-assessment, necessary for projects under incubation.  Taken
+together, this document and the joint-assessment serve as a cornerstone for if and when
+Lima seeks graduation and is preparing for a security audit.
+
+## Security functions and features
+
+<!--
+* Critical.  A listing critical security components of the project with a brief
+description of their importance.  It is recommended these be used for threat modeling.
+These are considered critical design elements that make the product itself secure and
+are not configurable.  Projects are encouraged to track these as primary impact items
+for changes to the project.
+* Security Relevant.  A listing of security relevant components of the project with
+  brief description.  These are considered important to enhance the overall security of
+the project, such as deployment configurations, settings, etc.  These should also be
+included in threat modeling.
+-->
+
+* The security of Lima critically depends on VM drivers (e.g., QEMU, Virtualization.framework),
+  SSH, SFTP, etc.
+  Users have to make sure to install the well-maintained version of these dependencies.
+  On macOS hosts, this can be typically accomplished by clicking the "Software Update" button of the System Preference,
+  and by running `brew upgrade`.
+
+## Project compliance
+
+<!--
+* Compliance.  List any security standards or sub-sections the project is
+  already documented as meeting (PCI-DSS, COBIT, ISO, GDPR, etc.).
+-->
+
+N/A
+
+## Secure development practices
+
+<!--
+* Development Pipeline.  A description of the testing and assessment processes that
+  the software undergoes as it is developed and built. Be sure to include specific
+information such as if contributors are required to sign commits, if any container
+images immutable and signed, how many reviewers before merging, any automated checks for
+vulnerabilities, etc.
+* Communication Channels. Reference where you document how to reach your team or
+  describe in corresponding section.
+  * Internal. How do team members communicate with each other?
+  * Inbound. How do users or prospective users communicate with the team?
+  * Outbound. How do you communicate with your users? (e.g. flibble-announce@
+    mailing list)
+* Ecosystem. How does your software fit into the cloud native ecosystem?  (e.g.
+  Flibber is integrated with both Flocker and Noodles which covers
+virtualization for 80% of cloud users. So, our small number of "users" actually
+represents very wide usage across the ecosystem since every virtual instance uses
+Flibber encryption by default.)
+-->
+
+* Development Pipeline:
+  * Every commit must be signed off with DCO, and every non-trivial commit must be approved by at least one other Maintainer (Committer or Reviewer).
+    See <https://lima-vm.io/docs/community/contributing/> for the further information.
+  * Dependabot is enabled to bump up Go dependencies automatically:
+    <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/blob/master/.github/dependabot.yml>
+  * Vulnerabilities of the Go dependencies are occasionally scanned with [govulncheck](https://pkg.go.dev/golang.org/x/vuln/cmd/govulncheck)
+  * CodeQL is enabled. Maintainers can see the results in <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/security>.
+
+* Communication Channels:
+  GitHub and Slack. See <https://lima-vm.io/docs/community/>.
+
+* Ecosystem:
+  Lima has been widely adopted in several third-party projects, such as:
+  * [Rancher Desktop](https://rancherdesktop.io/): Kubernetes and container management to the desktop
+  * [Colima](https://github.com/abiosoft/colima): Docker (and Kubernetes) on macOS with minimal setup
+  * [Finch](https://github.com/runfinch/finch): Finch is a command line client for local container development
+  * [Podman Desktop](https://podman-desktop.io/): Podman Desktop GUI has a plug-in for Lima virtual machines
+
+## Security issue resolution
+
+<!--
+* Responsible Disclosures Process. A outline of the project's responsible
+  disclosures process should suspected security issues, incidents, or
+vulnerabilities be discovered both external and internal to the project. The
+outline should discuss communication methods/strategies.
+  * Vulnerability Response Process. Who is responsible for responding to a
+    report. What is the reporting process? How would you respond?
+* Incident Response. A description of the defined procedures for triage,
+  confirmation, notification of vulnerability or security incident, and
+patching/update availability.
+-->
+
+* Responsible Disclosures Process:
+  Vulnerabilities are expected to be reported via <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/security/advisories/new>.
+  Those who do not have a GitHub account may also use email to reach out to the Committers directly.
+
+* Incident Response:
+  Committers triage and confirm potential vulnerability reports, and ship a fix as soon as possible.
+  Committers may coordinate with well-known downstream projects (e.g., Rancher Desktop, Colima, and Finch) for
+  a disclosure of a serial vulnerability.
+
+## Appendix
+
+<!--
+* Known Issues Over Time. List or summarize statistics of past vulnerabilities
+  with links. If none have been reported, provide data, if any, about your track
+record in catching issues in code review or automated testing.
+* [CII Best Practices](https://www.coreinfrastructure.org/programs/best-practices-program/).
+  Best Practices. A brief discussion of where the project is at
+  with respect to CII best practices and what it would need to
+  achieve the badge.
+* Case Studies. Provide context for reviewers by detailing 2-3 scenarios of
+  real-world use cases.
+* Related Projects / Vendors. Reflect on times prospective users have asked
+  about the differences between your project and projectX. Reviewers will have
+the same question.
+-->
+
+* Known Issues Over Time: See <https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/security/advisories>.
+  * [GHSA-f7qw-jj9c-rpq9](https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/security/advisories/GHSA-f7qw-jj9c-rpq9) (May 30, 2023):
+    A virtual machine instance with a malicious disk image could read a single file on the host filesystem, even when no filesystem is mounted from the host.
+    Fixed in Lima v0.16.0, by prohibiting using a backing file path in the VM base image.
+
+* CII Best Practices: See <https://www.bestpractices.dev/en/projects/6505>. Passing.
+
+* Case Studies: See Rancher Desktop (SUSE), Colima, Finch (AWS) below.
+
+* Related Projects / Vendors:
+  * [Rancher Desktop](https://rancherdesktop.io/): Kubernetes and container management to the desktop
+  * [Colima](https://github.com/abiosoft/colima): Docker (and Kubernetes) on macOS with minimal setup
+  * [Finch](https://github.com/runfinch/finch): Finch is a command line client for local container development
+  * [Podman Desktop](https://podman-desktop.io/): Podman Desktop GUI has a plug-in for Lima virtual machines
+  * [lima-xbar-plugin](https://github.com/unixorn/lima-xbar-plugin): xbar plugin to start/stop VMs from the menu bar and see their running status.
+  * [lima-gui](https://github.com/afbjorklund/lima-gui): Qt GUI for Lima