Request: questions about the results of your paper

[RuijunShi]

Hi @abhisrkckl ,

When running the program example5.py and example6.py, the results I've got were inconsistent with the ones based on the previous research paper (Susobhanan et al., 2020, figure 4 and figure 5). Then I made some adjustments on the parameters of the location of pulsar and the binary, but the results were still inconsistent with with the ones in Susobhanan et al. 2020.

I don't change the source code in GWecc and install GWecc according to readme. Running gcc-9.4.0 and python-3.8.13. Do I need to configure other software?

Another thing needed mentioning is that I have got the consistent results with another of your research paper Susobhanan et al. 2022 with running other example programs. The parameter Pb in line 52 of eccentric_hpx.py is different from Susobhanan et al. 2020 and the result would be consistent with figure1 in Susobhanan et al. 2020. when setting Pb to 1.5.

M = 1e9 * MSun
q = 1
Pb = 2 * year
n0 = 2 * np.pi / Pb
DGW = 1e9 * parsec

Thanks for the time reading my request.

My result:

Figure5 in Susobhanan et al.:

[abhisrkckl]

Sorry for missing this issue for so long.

I think the difference is in the pulsar distance. Can you try changing the pulsar distance?