Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

track count of multisig sessions opened between two dates #10

Closed
divine-comedian opened this issue Jun 7, 2024 · 24 comments
Closed

track count of multisig sessions opened between two dates #10

divine-comedian opened this issue Jun 7, 2024 · 24 comments
Assignees
Labels

Comments

@divine-comedian
Copy link
Contributor

in order to track how often the multisig integration feature is being used we should find a way to track how many multisig sessions were opened between two given dates.

@CarlosQ96 knows where to find this information

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 9, 2024

@divine-comedian
After fix the preview by Ramin, now, we can start test it via this link: https://analytics-dashboard-1uj2mh95z-givethio.vercel.app/

@ae2079 ae2079 moved this from Code Review/PR to QA in All-Devs Jul 9, 2024
@divine-comedian
Copy link
Contributor Author

@LatifatAbdullahi - here's how to test this issue:

  1. create or connect to an existing safe multisig on base sepolia or gnosis chain (those are the only two test networks that both Safe and Giveth support https://app.safe.global/welcome/accounts

I recommend creating a new multisig with 2/2 signers - using two addresses you control, use two separate browsers to connect with each signer (firefox / brave / chrome are all good options)

  1. Check on the vercel link to see current # of tracked multisig session connections made https://analytics-dashboard-1uj2mh95z-givethio.vercel.app/

image

  1. Follow these instructions to connect to Giveth with your multisig ---> https://docs.giveth.io/dapps/multisigs
  2. When you've connected successfully does the count of sessions go up?
  3. repeat steps 1-4 on another chain

@LatifatAbdullahi
Copy link

Noted.

@LatifatAbdullahi
Copy link

@ae2079

The Dashboard keeps throwing this error

image

Also, I would like to have a call with you when you are available please before dropping my feedback on the test

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 10, 2024

@ae2079

The Dashboard keeps throwing this error

image

Also, I would like to have a call with you when you are available please before dropping my feedback on the test

I will check this error with @mohammadranjbarz
and I will DM you on Discord to schedule a call

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 10, 2024

@ae2079

The Dashboard keeps throwing this error

image

Also, I would like to have a call with you when you are available please before dropping my feedback on the test

The error is fixed now, you can start your tests with this link:
https://analytics-dashboard-q4j1m7o0a-givethio.vercel.app/

@divine-comedian
Copy link
Contributor Author

@LatifatAbdullahi - what is the status update of the QA?

@LatifatAbdullahi
Copy link

I would have to retest the task to give an update, I had to pause since bugs were still being fixed

@LatifatAbdullahi
Copy link

@ae2079
The Dashboard keeps throwing this error
image
Also, I would like to have a call with you when you are available please before dropping my feedback on the test

The error is fixed now, you can start your tests with this link: https://analytics-dashboard-q4j1m7o0a-givethio.vercel.app/

I missed this comment, thanks I will check

@LatifatAbdullahi
Copy link

LatifatAbdullahi commented Jul 16, 2024

@divine-comedian @ae2079

Using this link (https://analytics-dashboard-q4j1m7o0a-givethio.vercel.app/), this issue is fixed

image

Based on this Step " When you've connected successfully does the count of sessions go up? "

Gnosis Chain

Using a safe account created with Gnosis chain and with 2 signers, connecting successfully to the Giveth staging with each signer on chrome and mozilla does not count on the Analytics for Multisig session. The count only reflected when a transaction was done and signed by both signers on separate browsers.

image

Base Sepolia

Using a safe account created with Base Sepolia and with 2 signers, connecting successfully to the Giveth staging with each signer on chrome and mozilla does not count on the Analytics for Multisig session.

@mateodaza
Copy link
Member

@divine-comedian I have a concern that I discussed with @LatifatAbdullahi
I'm not entirely sure how the analytics are working but if they're being tracked on the frontend the fact that the multisig is inside an iframe could cause some unexpected issues.. I would suggest managing this from the authentication microservice in the backend if possible. I'm not sure who set this up to double check

@divine-comedian
Copy link
Contributor Author

@ae2079 - that's for you, I don't have a strong opinion on what method we use to track the information, as long as it is reliable..

And to clarify from Latifat's testing - we should be tracking the moment from when a multisig session is opened - not from when a transaction is made from a multisig.

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

@divine-comedian I have a concern that I discussed with @LatifatAbdullahi I'm not entirely sure how the analytics are working but if they're being tracked on the frontend the fact that the multisig is inside an iframe could cause some unexpected issues.. I would suggest managing this from the authentication microservice in the backend if possible. I'm not sure who set this up to double check

yes, I use swieAuthMicroservice for that, and I get the data from multisigSessions repository

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

@ae2079 - that's for you, I don't have a strong opinion on what method we use to track the information, as long as it is reliable..

And to clarify from Latifat's testing - we should be tracking the moment from when a multisig session is opened - not from when a transaction is made from a multisig.

Based on the implementation, it seems there are no dependencies with donations, but I will double-check it and test it.
How can I create a multisig session on staging? @divine-comedian

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

@mateodaza it seems the login issue still exists on the staging because I tried many times to sign messages in the safe wallet and after a while it didn't apply to the staging app and I am still not logged in.
Screenshot 2024-07-16 234447
Screenshot 2024-07-16 234501

I gave this query from @CarlosQ96 to create a multisig session manually on the database:

INSERT INTO public.multisig_session
("safeMessageHash", "multisigAddress", "expirationDate", "createdAt", "updatedAt", "approvalExpirationDate", active, network, status)
VALUES
('0x249639e0af0157c3a53ef27565f2a6a26011ea46003b0605d8035f7516e6fefb', -- safeMessageHash
 '0x40891ce6e8574bb9118913a8a304195437f36213', -- multisigAddress
 CURRENT_DATE + INTERVAL '3 months', -- expirationDate
 CURRENT_DATE, -- createdAt
 CURRENT_DATE, -- updatedAt
 CURRENT_DATE + INTERVAL '3 months', -- approvalExpirationDate
 TRUE, -- active
 10, -- network
 'successful' -- status
);

and after executing this query, the amount of multisig sessions increased correctly:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 022840

@LatifatAbdullahi I think the problem may be related to multisig sessions issue on the staging because the metrics increased for me without making any donation.

@divine-comedian For releasing this feature, we need to deploy changes on the swieAuth microservice first, and these changes did not affect other features so we can deploy them independently.

@mateodaza
Copy link
Member

@mateodaza it seems the login issue still exists on the staging because I tried many times to sign messages in the safe wallet and after a while it didn't apply to the staging app and I am still not logged in.

Screenshot 2024-07-16 234447

Screenshot 2024-07-16 234501

I gave this query from @CarlosQ96 to create a multisig session manually on the database:


INSERT INTO public.multisig_session

("safeMessageHash", "multisigAddress", "expirationDate", "createdAt", "updatedAt", "approvalExpirationDate", active, network, status)

VALUES

('0x249639e0af0157c3a53ef27565f2a6a26011ea46003b0605d8035f7516e6fefb', -- safeMessageHash

 '0x40891ce6e8574bb9118913a8a304195437f36213', -- multisigAddress

 CURRENT_DATE + INTERVAL '3 months', -- expirationDate

 CURRENT_DATE, -- createdAt

 CURRENT_DATE, -- updatedAt

 CURRENT_DATE + INTERVAL '3 months', -- approvalExpirationDate

 TRUE, -- active

 10, -- network

 'successful' -- status

);

and after executing this query, the amount of multisig sessions increased correctly:

Screenshot 2024-07-17 022840

@LatifatAbdullahi I think the problem may be related to multisig sessions issue on the staging because the metrics increased for me without making any donation.

@divine-comedian For releasing this feature, we need to deploy changes on the swieAuth microservice first, and these changes did not affect other features so we can deploy them independently.

You still need to sign with your signer address every single time, according to your screenshot you still miss that step

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

@mateodaza I checked the multisig_sessions table and there was no entry for my multisig wallet address and also checked the code and saw there is no config for network ID that relates to base sepolia network, maybe this can help you to find the issue

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

@mateodaza it seems the login issue still exists on the staging because I tried many times to sign messages in the safe wallet and after a while it didn't apply to the staging app and I am still not logged in.
Screenshot 2024-07-16 234447
Screenshot 2024-07-16 234501
I gave this query from @CarlosQ96 to create a multisig session manually on the database:


INSERT INTO public.multisig_session

("safeMessageHash", "multisigAddress", "expirationDate", "createdAt", "updatedAt", "approvalExpirationDate", active, network, status)

VALUES

('0x249639e0af0157c3a53ef27565f2a6a26011ea46003b0605d8035f7516e6fefb', -- safeMessageHash

 '0x40891ce6e8574bb9118913a8a304195437f36213', -- multisigAddress

 CURRENT_DATE + INTERVAL '3 months', -- expirationDate

 CURRENT_DATE, -- createdAt

 CURRENT_DATE, -- updatedAt

 CURRENT_DATE + INTERVAL '3 months', -- approvalExpirationDate

 TRUE, -- active

 10, -- network

 'successful' -- status

);

and after executing this query, the amount of multisig sessions increased correctly:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 022840
@LatifatAbdullahi I think the problem may be related to multisig sessions issue on the staging because the metrics increased for me without making any donation.
@divine-comedian For releasing this feature, we need to deploy changes on the swieAuth microservice first, and these changes did not affect other features so we can deploy them independently.

You still need to sign with your signer address every single time, according to your screenshot you still miss that step

I think I do that, let me do it again to ensure that

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

first I open the app from the safe wallet webpage, then I click on my MyAccount, and this pop-up is shown:
Screenshot 2024-07-16 234447

then I click on sign in button and select a 1 week duration for example:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 025239

after clicking on 'let's do it' button, I have to sign this message with my Metamask wallet:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 025254

after that, I redirected to the safe message signing page and signed it with my Metamast again:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 030031

Screenshot 2024-07-17 030045

after signing it, I was redirected to this page again:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 030207

and after that, when I closed the pop-up and selected myAccount again, I faced this pop-up again (without reloading the page):
Screenshot 2024-07-17 025334

@mateodaza if I missed any steps, let me know what should I exactly do, thanks

@mateodaza
Copy link
Member

first I open the app from the safe wallet webpage, then I click on my MyAccount, and this pop-up is shown:

Screenshot 2024-07-16 234447

then I click on sign in button and select a 1 week duration for example:

Screenshot 2024-07-17 025239

after clicking on 'let's do it' button, I have to sign this message with my Metamask wallet:

Screenshot 2024-07-17 025254

after that, I redirected to the safe message signing page and signed it with my Metamast again:

Screenshot 2024-07-17 030031

Screenshot 2024-07-17 030045

after signing it, I was redirected to this page again:

Screenshot 2024-07-17 030207

and after that, when I closed the pop-up and selected myAccount again, I faced this pop-up again (without reloading the page):

Screenshot 2024-07-17 025334

@mateodaza if I missed any steps, let me know what should I exactly do, thanks

Can you please test it with a multisig of 2 signers at least? - there's an edge case for 1 signer multisigs that we haven't tackled yet

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 16, 2024

first I open the app from the safe wallet webpage, then I click on my MyAccount, and this pop-up is shown:
Screenshot 2024-07-16 234447
then I click on sign in button and select a 1 week duration for example:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 025239
after clicking on 'let's do it' button, I have to sign this message with my Metamask wallet:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 025254
after that, I redirected to the safe message signing page and signed it with my Metamast again:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 030031
Screenshot 2024-07-17 030045
after signing it, I was redirected to this page again:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 030207
and after that, when I closed the pop-up and selected myAccount again, I faced this pop-up again (without reloading the page):
Screenshot 2024-07-17 025334
@mateodaza if I missed any steps, let me know what should I exactly do, thanks

Can you please test it with a multisig of 2 signers at least? - there's an edge case for 1 signer multisigs that we haven't tackled yet

Oh, ok, I'll do that

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 17, 2024

@LatifatAbdullahi
I signed in using a safe account with two signers in the gnosis chain and without any donations, the metric increased:
Screenshot 2024-07-17 035115

Screenshot 2024-07-17 035020

I tried to create a new safe wallet with two singers on base sepolia, but it seems there are some issues(maybe because it is a test net) with the help of @mateodaza, I created a wallet and tested on the gnosis chain

FYI @divine-comedian

@ae2079
Copy link
Collaborator

ae2079 commented Jul 18, 2024

@divine-comedian
I created two branches for releasing this feature when you approved it:
for the back-end: Giveth/SiweAuthMicroservice#29 (I think @CarlosQ96 should deploy this service)
for the front-end: #23 (we should merge it after the backend deployed)

@divine-comedian
Copy link
Contributor Author

looks like this all merged on production! great

@github-project-automation github-project-automation bot moved this from QA to Done in All-Devs Jul 23, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
Status: Done
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants