Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Request: emulation of inside PCB #569

Open
joep2000 opened this issue Oct 31, 2024 · 21 comments
Open

Request: emulation of inside PCB #569

joep2000 opened this issue Oct 31, 2024 · 21 comments

Comments

@joep2000
Copy link

The gen M doesn't have the inside PCB like previous models. Only connections possible are 3-way valve, tank sensor, TAW1. (Unless you purchase the controlbox, hydraubox or all-in-one).
It would be nice that HeishaMon can emulate the inside PCB, same as the optional board (connection of external thermostat, extra pump, buffer sensor/heater, etc)

@MiG-41
Copy link
Contributor

MiG-41 commented Nov 1, 2024

If it doesn't have anything extra , how to emulate it ? Probably it is not accepting that commands from Optional PCB.
First it would be nice to somone have this HP , confirm ,that standard CZ-TAW1 works with it , do some sniffing , ect.

@joep2000
Copy link
Author

joep2000 commented Nov 1, 2024

@MiG-41
Some more background. I own a 12kW gen M (WH-WXG12ME8 with Remote Control CZ-RTW2TAW1C) that is connected with the Heishamon large PBC and the TAW1. From fist observations I can confirm that both are working.

However the gen M is a bit of a different beast. The 'cheap' version doesn't come with the indoor PCB as described above. Just the pump and the remote control. Only connections possible are for DHW tank option: 3way valve and tank sensor. So the bare minimum.
Pay 1200€ extra and you'll get the 'control box'. This box communicates with the pump and includes the indoor PCB: all of the connections you'll normally find in a Pana pump.

Other options are the 'Bi-block' which includes a heating element.
Or the All-In-One, which includes all ;-) (DHW, heating element, controls).
With these indoor options for the gen M, you have the optional PCB as well.

So, emulating the indoor PCB would help spectacularly (for saving space inside and €€€)

I can do sniffing etc with help of some directions.

@MiG-41
Copy link
Contributor

MiG-41 commented Nov 1, 2024

Maybe first you could tell ,how this 'control box' looks like , how it would be connected to mainboard of M series ? Maybe some pictures of M PCB board ? ( i know that this could be found , there are also probably service manual for M series already , but you have to also understand ,that users with are own HP previous generations not following the changes with such entusiasm as before :) )

@joep2000
Copy link
Author

joep2000 commented Nov 1, 2024

Sure, I understand that the M has just launched, and it is a T-CAP. However, I think Panasonic is moving in this direction to decrease the price of the main unit. So consider this work for future benefit (and my benefit for now).

Indoor units communicate with a 2 wire interface (I have no idea which one, but probably Modbus or some variation). TAW1 connection is also available.

So let me help myself figuring out how to tackle this. Help appriciated!

@MiG-41
Copy link
Contributor

MiG-41 commented Nov 1, 2024

2 wire interface could be similar to one , with communicates with display controller... For with we are also not able to influence ( you can't set a data ,clock , brithness , edit schedules ect).

EDIT: Do you have some pictures , service manual link ? For that HP ? ( since i can't find anything interesting).

@joep2000
Copy link
Author

joep2000 commented Nov 1, 2024

unit inside:
20240816_125635

in a sealed box (R290) on top all power electronics:
20240817_123453
20240817_123457
20240817_123501

Service manual is pretty thin though (took out a few pages to shrink below 25Mb. ).
Also, this docuement is focused on the All-In-One:
(EN) Panasonic M-gen service manual.pdf

@MiG-41
Copy link
Contributor

MiG-41 commented Nov 1, 2024

From this:
image

You can see , that communication beetween ( here also called ) OPTIONAL is via second CN-CNT ( or first ,since second is called CN-CNT2 and it is for Network adabter - assumption CZ-TAW1).

So only thing with is needed is to sniff comunication beetween this two devices ( but to sniff you need them booth).

EDIT: There is also a chance that CN-CNT and CN-CNT2 are the same serial , shortcuted on board. It is easy to check via multimeter ,( when HP is off from power). That is also first thing to be checked.

EDIT2:
And this shows ,that you have all connections whot previous models:
image

Or even more , since "anode system" is something new ....

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 1, 2024

It's everything same as in previous versions, and with k/l boards.. i think even same optional(expansion) board.
As for anode, yes it have active anode in boiler, previous boiler's don't even have any anode.

Difference from H/J series that some element's are moved from expansion board to main board. So everything what is on mainboard can't be emulated.

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 1, 2024

unit inside: 20240816_125635

in a sealed box (R290) on top all power electronics: 20240817_123453 20240817_123457 20240817_123501

Service manual is pretty thin though (took out a few pages to shrink below 25Mb. ). Also, this docuement is focused on the All-In-One: (EN) Panasonic M-gen service manual.pdf

It's just outdoor unit boards, you're missing main board, could it be behind screws where paper attached?

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 1, 2024

According to service manual it's hydro-split unit, so main board in inside unit, and it's looking same as k/l series.. do we are missing something? Do you have inside unit? Or just outside?

@joep2000
Copy link
Author

joep2000 commented Nov 2, 2024

@MiG-41 You are describing the indoor unit
@geduxas yes you are missing something :-)

chapter 9.2 (p79 of service manual) describes the outdoor unit. Only connections are:
-3phase power connection
-tank sensor (CN-TH)
-Remote controller (CN-RC)
-TAW1 (and heishamon) (CN-CNT)
-indoor unit (CN-DATA)
image

AND:
-3way valve (CN-V3)
-boiler contact (CN-CONCTACT)
image

Both main PCB and Optional PCB are in the indoor units. Which are:

  • Control Box (WH-CME8)
  • Bi-Bloc T-CAP (WH-SDC0316M9E8)
  • Al-In-One T-CAP (WH-ADC0316M9E82) (the service manual is for this one, so, hence the confusion above)

I only have the outdoor unit. Misinformed by the sales people, it only has the few connections stated above. I hope Heishamon can eventualy replace the indoor units, since they start from 1200€.

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 2, 2024

Oh, so i thought right, yes ODU and IDU are sold separately all time, just didn't though it could run standalone. But i have som thought's about hydro-split units, because it doesn't seemed something ok with that.. now i understand.. ok, so you don't have inside unit.. but your almost have minim what is needed for pump to operate..

So what you're missing? What still needs to be emulated?

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 2, 2024

It would be nice that HeishaMon can emulate the inside PCB, same as the optional board (connection of external thermostat, extra pump, buffer sensor/heater, etc)

External thermostat it's in main pcb.. it could be possible or impossible to emulate i think it will require more data.. somewhere should be all pump logic, naturally it's on inside unit (but questionable).

Extra pump (you are talking about pump per zone?) It's emulated
Buffer sensor also emulated..

Have you tested emulated setting while connecting to cn-cnt? Or you even don't have possibility to enable expansion board from RC?

What about jumperwire which is required for stand alone operation, have you tried to remove it?

@joep2000
Copy link
Author

joep2000 commented Nov 3, 2024

I haven't tried removing the jumperwire. I guess that the HP then expects it has a main board, but it hasn't. So probably won't do anything except throw an error...

I cannot select the Optional board in the settings, so I guess that is out of the question for emulating all the extra's I'd like.

  • Extra pump: I'm running with a parrallel-buffer. Extra pump is just to switch with the main pump. This can be done with rules in Heishamon, so not really important at this point.
  • Buffer sensor is emulated in Optional Board? Can't see it in the MQTT topic list, anyway, at the moment can't do that since I dont have the optional board
  • SG, would be nice

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 3, 2024

Ok, so yes, i think by removing jumperwire it will forward logic to main board.. so it won't work in this situation. It will require additional investigation on port and protocol.

For that we needed volunteers with full setup and dataloger, to analyze traffic..

@MiG-41
Copy link
Contributor

MiG-41 commented Nov 3, 2024

  • Extra pump: I'm running with a parrallel-buffer. Extra pump is just to switch with the main pump. This can be done with rules in Heishamon, so not really important at this point.

Extra Pump also not working ,when DHW is boiling... but that is deatail.

  • Buffer sensor is emulated in Optional Board? Can't see it in the MQTT topic list, anyway, at the moment can't do that since I dont have the optional board

Yes ,on optional PCB there is a Buffer sensor to be placed on the top of buffer. That is one of least reverse enginered function , since no one is using this , and next case is that it apear also next delta ( additional temperature ) with is higher in buffer....
With is silly and loosing CAP , since HP is heating additional temp. with is storaging in buffer , and for floor is going cooler water...

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 3, 2024

@MiG-41 i have buffer, with 2 zones.. so yes, buffer target temperature is highest zone target temperature plus buffer delta. Original 50L buffer comes with temperature sensor in midle.

@MiG-41
Copy link
Contributor

MiG-41 commented Nov 3, 2024

But you are using it ? You have real Optional PCB ? If yes , you could investigate for with Byte09 in OptionalPCB command is ( i belive it is something related to the buffer , but never had a chance to check it).

@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Nov 4, 2024

Yes i have everything needed for 2 zones. Ill do my best to investigate byte 09 in my setup.

Copy link

github-actions bot commented Dec 5, 2024

This issue is stale because it has been open 30 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 5 days.

@github-actions github-actions bot added the Stale label Dec 5, 2024
@geduxas
Copy link
Contributor

geduxas commented Dec 5, 2024

month passed :D and i still not started anything

@github-actions github-actions bot removed the Stale label Dec 6, 2024
@geduxas geduxas mentioned this issue Dec 13, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants