diff --git a/lib/compare-with-baseline.js b/lib/compare-with-baseline.js
index 9752464..e864773 100644
--- a/lib/compare-with-baseline.js
+++ b/lib/compare-with-baseline.js
@@ -70,7 +70,7 @@ module.exports = function compareWithBaseline(
                         completeDiffPath,
                         diff.image
                     ), resolve)
-                    .then(() => promptScreenshotOverride(
+                    .then(() =>     (
                         completeLatestPath,
                         completeBaselinePath,
                         completeDiffPath
@@ -98,6 +98,23 @@ module.exports = function compareWithBaseline(
                         resolve(true)
                     })
                     .catch(() => resolve(false))
+            } else if (!identical && !prompt && !always_save_diff_screenshot) {
+                saveScreenshot(
+                    completeLatestPath,
+                    screenshot
+                )
+                    .then(() => saveScreenshot(
+                        completeDiffPath,
+                        diff.image
+                    ), resolve)
+                    .then(() =>     (
+                        completeLatestPath,
+                        completeBaselinePath,
+                        completeDiffPath
+                    ), resolve)
+                    .then(
+                        resolve
+                    )
             } else if (identical) {
                 // Cleanup here in case user fixed bug and reran tests
                 cleanupScreenshots(