Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Misaligned Tiles #77

Open
lukezirngibl opened this issue Apr 3, 2023 · 4 comments
Open

Misaligned Tiles #77

lukezirngibl opened this issue Apr 3, 2023 · 4 comments

Comments

@lukezirngibl
Copy link

lukezirngibl commented Apr 3, 2023

Hey Chris,

I seem to be getting misaligned tiles when generating.

Aligned bottom:
Screen Shot 2023-04-03 at 15 57 57

Aligned ridge (misaligned bottom):
Screen Shot 2023-04-03 at 16 02 43

My config:

          "trlat": 47.88266953319475,# bottom left corner lat
          "trlon": 10.707753906131003,# bottom left corner long
          "bllat": 45.62561851186426, #top right corner lat
          "bllon": 5.813401946902514,# top right corner long
          "importedDEM": "./data.tif", # if not None, the raster file to use as DEM instead of using GEE (null in JSON)
          "printres": 0.5,  # resolution (horizontal) of 3D printer (= size of one pixel) in mm
          "ntilesx": 9,      # number of tiles in x and y
          "ntilesy": 6,
          "tilewidth": 100, # width of each tile in mm (<- !!!!!), tile height is calculated
          "basethick": 15, # thickness (in mm) of printed base
          "zscale": 1.0,      # elevation (vertical) scaling
          "fileformat": "STLb",  # format of 3D model files: "obj" wavefront obj (ascii),"STLa" ascii STL or "STLb" binary STL
          "tile_centered": False, # True-> all tiles are centered around 0/0, False, all tiles "fit together"
          "zip_file_name": "alps",   # base name of zipfile, .zip will be added
          "CPU_cores_to_use" : 0,  # 0 means all cores, None (null in JSON!) => don't use multiprocessing
          "max_cells_for_memory_only" : 1000 * 1000, # if raster is bigger, use temp_files instead of memory
          "no_bottom": False, # omit bottom triangles?
          #"rot_degs": 0, # rotate by degrees ccw  # CH disabled for now
          "bottom_image": None,  # 1 band greyscale image used for bottom relief
          "ignore_leq": None, # set values <= this to NaN, so they are ignored
          "lower_leq": None,  # e.g. [0.0, 2.0] values <= 0.0 will be lowered by 2mm in the final model
          "unprojected": False, # don't project to UTM, only usefull when using GEE for DEM rasters
          "only": None,# list of tile index [x,y] with is the only tile to be processed. None means process all tiles (index is 1 based)
          "poly_file": None, #"idaho.kml", #TT_poly_test.kml",
          "smooth_borders": True, # smooth borders

logfile:

Log for creating 9 x 6 3D model tile(s) from data.tif 
 
started: 16:25:38.556908 
source raster upper left corner (x/y):  229110.0 5305650.0 
source raster cells size 30.0 m  (7769, 13815) 
projection: WGS 84 / UTM zone 32N 
z-scale: 1.3 
basethickness: 15 
fileformat: STLb 
tile_centered: False 
no_bottom: False 
no_normals: True 
ignore_leq: None 
lower_leq: None 
importedGPX: None 
undefined GDAL value: None 
tile_width: 100 
tile_height: 56.23597538906985 
source raster width 414450.0 m, cell size: 30.0 m, elev. min/max is 40.0 4809.0 m 
source raster 3D print resolution would be 0.06514657980456026 mm 
re-sampling data.tif :
  (13815, 7769) 0.06514657980456026 mm  30.0 m  40.0 - 4809.0 m to 
  (1800, 1012) 0.5 mm  230.25 m  59.468372 - 4736.3257 m 
print res is 0.5 mm 
Cropping for nice fit of 9 (width) x 6 (height) tiles, removing: 0 columns, 4 rows 
 cropped (1800, 1012) to (1800, 1008) 
 cropping changed physical size from 100 mm x 84.33333333333333 mm 
 to 100.0 mm x 84.0 mm 
map scale is 1 : 460500.0 
Cells per tile (x/y) 200 x 168 
using single-core only 

9 x 6 tiles, tile size 100.00 x 84.00 mm
 
tile 1 1 : height:  191.6655 - 15.802115 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 1 2 : height:  183.84213 - 15.860547 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 1 3 : height:  191.79538 - 17.04288 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 1 4 : height:  195.88974 - 18.080755 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 1 5 : height:  291.8095 - 18.951483 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 1 6 : height:  225.69896 - 19.047348 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 2 1 : height:  206.6946 - 16.24718 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 2 2 : height:  216.4829 - 17.125134 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 2 3 : height:  318.2327 - 18.50724 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 2 4 : height:  368.91043 - 18.62294 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 2 5 : height:  366.321 - 19.982578 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 2 6 : height:  427.32034 - 21.141172 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 3 1 : height:  246.68542 - 17.778305 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 3 2 : height:  297.28238 - 17.79468 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 3 3 : height:  422.0 - 18.236658 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 3 4 : height:  369.37585 - 20.451563 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 3 5 : height:  365.57553 - 22.839916 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 3 6 : height:  454.22202 - 27.088457 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 4 1 : height:  197.90182 - 18.331402 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 4 2 : height:  257.0738 - 18.244726 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 4 3 : height:  427.58197 - 17.398708 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 4 4 : height:  528.4612 - 22.796164 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 4 5 : height:  477.08356 - 24.418552 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 4 6 : height:  845.9084 - 25.337296 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 5 1 : height:  282.0828 - 18.356377 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 5 2 : height:  286.19427 - 16.958464 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 5 3 : height:  393.76727 - 21.491447 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 5 4 : height:  470.08173 - 25.131504 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 5 5 : height:  310.43695 - 25.670383 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 5 6 : height:  191.5922 - 26.507986 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 6 1 : height:  342.41873 - 16.677013 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 6 2 : height:  355.72488 - 17.600143 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 6 3 : height:  350.1448 - 22.64892 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 6 4 : height:  453.6622 - 23.638344 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 6 5 : height:  191.46535 - 23.769928 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 6 6 : height:  173.82703 - 20.547045 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 7 1 : height:  384.13315 - 16.263924 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 7 2 : height:  391.51416 - 20.61398 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 7 3 : height:  419.2372 - 22.603453 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 7 4 : height:  564.86 - 22.121048 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 7 5 : height:  181.94656 - 23.711742 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 7 6 : height:  180.76138 - 21.588915 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 8 1 : height:  401.62704 - 18.00505 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 8 2 : height:  391.97302 - 21.087027 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 8 3 : height:  490.00018 - 22.85838 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 8 4 : height:  979.11 - 21.507284 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 8 5 : height:  266.41058 - 25.268267 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 8 6 : height:  182.18958 - 22.7939 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 9 1 : height:  645.9717 - 18.776098 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 9 2 : height:  656.80676 - 20.969414 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 9 3 : height:  740.87946 - 23.244572 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 9 4 : height:  633.40533 - 23.986706 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 9 5 : height:  596.34216 - 23.880842 mm , file size: 3 Mb 
tile 9 6 : height:  59.468372 - 24.534832 mm , file size: 3 Mb 

total size for all tiles: 177 Mb 

processing finished: 16:26:05.614725 

Any idea what could be causing this? Thanks for your help!

@ChHarding
Copy link
Owner

ChHarding commented Apr 3, 2023 via email

@lukezirngibl
Copy link
Author

yeah, it seems like the less tiles i have, the less the severe the misalignment is (which would make sense if its related to the lowest elevation computations)

@ChHarding
Copy link
Owner

ChHarding commented Apr 3, 2023 via email

@ChHarding
Copy link
Owner

Luke,

I messed something up during the min_height parameter implementation (as I had suspected) and it should be fixed now. Thanks for telling me!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants