diff --git a/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/Theme.java b/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/Theme.java
index 1039ecdb..c94b285c 100644
--- a/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/Theme.java
+++ b/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/Theme.java
@@ -12,11 +12,12 @@
 import com.nispok.snackbar.Snackbar;
 import com.nispok.snackbar.SnackbarManager;
 
-import io.fabric.sdk.android.Fabric;
 import net.somethingdreadful.MAL.account.AccountService;
 
 import java.util.Locale;
 
+import io.fabric.sdk.android.Fabric;
+
 public class Theme extends Application {
 
     public static boolean darkTheme;
@@ -150,7 +151,7 @@ else if (score <= 60)
                 Double score5 = Math.floor(score / 10);
                 return score5 > 0.0 ? String.format("%.1f", score5) : "?";
             default:
-                return String.format("%.0f", Math.floor(score / 10));
+                return "?";
         }
     }
 
diff --git a/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/dialog/NumberPickerDialogFragment.java b/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/dialog/NumberPickerDialogFragment.java
index 8f61a2ff..8686f578 100644
--- a/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/dialog/NumberPickerDialogFragment.java
+++ b/Atarashii/src/net/somethingdreadful/MAL/dialog/NumberPickerDialogFragment.java
@@ -19,7 +19,6 @@
 import net.somethingdreadful.MAL.account.AccountService;
 
 public class NumberPickerDialogFragment extends DialogFragment {
-
     NumberPicker numberPicker;
     EditText numberInput;
     private onUpdateClickListener callback;
@@ -36,10 +35,12 @@ private View makeNumberPicker() {
         if (!inputScore) {
             numberPicker.setMaxValue(max != 0 ? max : 999);
             numberPicker.setMinValue(0);
-            if (!AccountService.isMAL() && isRating())
-                numberPicker.setValue(Integer.parseInt(Theme.getDisplayScore(current)));
-            else
+            if (!AccountService.isMAL() && isRating()) {
+                String score = Theme.getDisplayScore(current);
+                numberPicker.setValue(score.equals("?") ? 0 : Integer.parseInt(score));
+            } else {
                 numberPicker.setValue(current);
+            }
             numberInput.setVisibility(View.GONE);
         } else {
             numberInput.setText(Theme.getDisplayScore(current));